The Absolute Best Italian Restaurant in New Braunfels [Updated 2024]

From pasta connoisseur to pizza enthusiast, I have done the delicious duty of sampling and reviewing fifteen Italian restaurants in this charming city. Get ready to embark on a lighthearted culinary journey where I share my top pick for the best Italian dining experience.

So, whether you're craving a mouthwatering plate of spaghetti carbonara or a perfectly thin-crust margherita pizza, sit back, relax, and let me take you on a flavorful adventure through New Braunfels' finest Italian cuisine. Let's dig in!

Noli's Vite

Highlights
Delicious food
Perfect sauce
Exquisite pasta

Let me start by saying that Noli's Vite truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best Italian restaurants in New Braunfels. From the moment I stepped through the doors, I was transported to the streets of Italy, surrounded by warm and inviting atmosphere.

The highlight of my dining experience at Noli's Vite was undoubtedly the delicious food. Every dish I sampled was a culinary masterpiece, bursting with authentic Italian flavors. The menu offered a wide variety of options, but I decided to indulge in their famous pasta dishes. And let me tell you, I was not disappointed.

The perfectly crafted sauce that accompanied the pasta was a symphony of flavors, each ingredient playing its part to perfection. It was clear that the chefs at Noli's Vite take great pride in their work, using only the freshest ingredients to create their culinary masterpieces.

Speaking of pasta, the noodles themselves were exquisite. Cooked to perfection, they were al dente and provided the perfect balance to the rich and flavorful sauces. Each bite was like a little taste of Italy on my tongue.

To top it all off, the service at Noli's Vite was exceptional. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.

If you're looking for an Italian restaurant that offers a combination of delicious food, perfect sauces, and exquisite pasta, look no further than Noli's Vite in New Braunfels. I guarantee you won't be disappointed. Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in San Antonio.

Bootleggers Pizza Parlor

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Quick service
Great atmosphere
Wonderful flavors
Variety of options

Upon entering Bootleggers Pizza Parlor, I was immediately drawn to the great atmosphere that enveloped the restaurant. The lively chatter and inviting aromas set the stage for an enjoyable dining experience.

As I perused the menu, I was delighted to see a variety of options to suit different tastes. From classic Margherita to inventive combinations like the Bootlegger's Special, there was something for everyone. I opted for the latter, and I must say, it did not disappoint.

The pizza that arrived at my table was a work of art; the combination of flavors and textures was simply divine. The crust was thin and crispy, providing the perfect base for the wonderful flavors that adorned it. Each bite was a harmonious blend of tangy tomato sauce, melted cheese, and a medley of fresh toppings.

Not only was the pizza delicious, but the quick service also impressed me. The attentive staff made sure I felt welcomed and attended to, ensuring a seamless dining experience.

In conclusion, Bootleggers Pizza Parlor truly deserves a spot in the discussion of the best Italian restaurants in New Braunfels. With its commitment to creating delicious pizza, great atmosphere, and providing a variety of options, it's no wonder locals and visitors alike flock to this gem. If you're looking for a playful yet professional Italian dining experience, give Bootleggers Pizza Parlor a try!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in San Antonio.

Above Ground Pizza

Highlights
Great food
Great atmosphere
Great prices
Clean and hospitable
Love for serving great pizza

As soon as I walked into Above Ground Pizza, I was immediately drawn to its great atmosphere. The restaurant had a cozy and welcoming vibe, with its rustic decor and warm lighting. It was the kind of place that made you feel like you were entering a friend's home.

But of course, a good atmosphere is only part of the equation. The true test lies in the food. And boy, did Above Ground Pizza deliver! The pizza I had was simply delicious. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was melted to perfection. Every bite was a burst of savory goodness.

What impressed me even more was the great prices at Above Ground Pizza. Italian food can often be on the pricier side, but this restaurant offers excellent value for money. You won't have to break the bank to enjoy a satisfying meal here.

The staff at Above Ground Pizza was incredibly friendly and attentive. They were quick to offer recommendations and were genuinely passionate about serving great pizza. The place was also exceptionally clean, which is always a plus.

Overall, my experience at Above Ground Pizza was a fantastic one. From the stellar food to the inviting atmosphere, this place exceeded my expectations. It truly deserves its spot as one of the best italian restaurants in New Braunfels. Don't miss out on this hidden gem!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Riverwalk San Antonio.

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels

Highlights
Best pizza in Texas!
Friendly owners and quick delivery.
Fresh ingredients and perfect sauce.
Outstanding customer service.

Let me tell you, this place is no joke when it comes to pizza. I'm not exaggerating when I say that Mattenga's Pizzeria serves the best pizza in Texas. From the moment I entered, I was greeted by the friendly owners who made me feel like a part of their family. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, and you could taste the quality in every bite. The crust was thin and crispy, just the way I like it. But what really stole the show was the sauce. It was perfection. Tangy, flavorful, and not overpowering. The combination of the sauce and the toppings created a symphony of flavors on my taste buds. I couldn't get enough!

In addition to the fantastic food, the customer service at Mattenga's Pizzeria was outstanding. The staff was attentive, ensuring that I had everything I needed throughout my meal. Even the delivery service was quick and reliable, making it a great option for those nights when you just don't feel like cooking.

Overall, Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels is an absolute gem of an italian restaurant. With its amazing pizza, friendly owners, and exceptional customer service, it truly deserves a place among the best in New Braunfels. Trust me, you won't be disappointed when you give this place a try.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in New Braunfels.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Plenty of food
Delicious
Great service
Swift service

Stepping into Olive Garden, an aroma of freshly baked bread and simmering sauces surrounded me, instantly transporting me to the heart of Italy. One thing I quickly realized about this Italian gem is they do not skimp on portion sizes. Prepare to be delighted by heaping plates and an abundance of deliciousness.

The menu at Olive Garden showcases a wide selection of traditional dishes, from classic pasta favorites to mouthwatering seafood creations. I found myself indulging in their Spaghetti and Meatballs, a comforting combination of tender pasta smothered in rich tomato sauce, topped with juicy meatballs. Each bite was a divine symphony of flavors, causing me to lose track of time as I savored the dish.

What impressed me the most, however, was the impeccable service at Olive Garden. The waitstaff was attentive, providing swift and friendly service. The moment I sat down, I was greeted with a warm smile and my server promptly took my order. It was clear that the staff truly cared about creating a memorable experience for all diners.

In addition to their generous portions and delightful flavors, Olive Garden delivers their delectable dishes with remarkable efficiency. Despite the bustling atmosphere, my food arrived swiftly, allowing me to enjoy my meal without delay.

For those seeking an unforgettable Italian dining experience in New Braunfels, Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is a must-visit. Just be sure to bring your appetite, as their portions are as generous as their flavors. With their delicious offerings, great service, and swift delivery, Olive Garden undoubtedly secures a spot on the list of the best Italian restaurants in town.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Boerne.

New York Pizza Pub

Highlights
NY trained pizza
Friendly staff
Wonderful atmosphere
Plenty of parking
Amazing food

Walking into New York Pizza Pub, I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff, who exuded genuine warmth and hospitality. The wonderful atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel like I had stepped into a cozy pizzeria in the heart of New York City.

What sets New York Pizza Pub apart from the rest is their commitment to authenticity. The owners have been trained in the art of pizza-making in the bustling streets of New York, and it truly shows in every bite. The pizza is a slice of heaven, with a perfectly crispy yet chewy crust that is the foundation for a medley of fresh and quality toppings. Each bite transported me to the bustling streets of Little Italy.

Aside from the incredible pizza, the menu offers a wide variety of traditional Italian dishes that are equally delightful. From the classic spaghetti and meatballs to the rich and creamy fettuccine Alfredo, every dish was expertly prepared and bursting with flavor.

The ample parking available made it convenient for us to visit, and the staff’s knowledge and passion for their craft made the dining experience even more enjoyable. Whether you're a pizza lover or a connoisseur of Italian cuisine, New York Pizza Pub is sure to satisfy your cravings.

In conclusion, New York Pizza Pub is a true gem. With its NY trained pizza, friendly staff, wonderful atmosphere, and amazing food, it has earned its spot as one of the best Italian restaurants in New Braunfels. So grab a slice, sit back, and indulge in a truly authentic Italian experience.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in San Antonio.

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits

Highlights
Cool and unique food and drink
Amazing food and great drinks
Quick service with wood-fired pizza
$5 margaritas
New go-to spot for pizza

Let me start by saying that this place is off the charts! Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits offers cool and unique food and drink options that will make your taste buds do a happy dance.

First things first, the food is amazing. The wood-fired pizza is a game-changer. Every bite was filled with the perfect combination of flavors and a crispy crust that was to die for. Quick service meant that I didn't have to wait long to get my hands on these mouthwatering pizzas.

But it's not just about the food, the drinks are equally impressive. They have an extensive menu of great drinks, but what caught my attention were the $5 margaritas. Yes, you read that right! Delicious margaritas at an unbeatable price. It added that extra touch of fun and made the experience even better.

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits has become my new go-to spot for pizza in New Braunfels. The combination of amazing food, great drinks, and friendly staff creates an atmosphere that is both lively and welcoming. Trust me, you won't be disappointed when you visit this Italian gem in town.

In conclusion, Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits deserves all the praise it gets. With cool and unique food and drink options, amazing food, and quick service with wood-fired pizza, it's no wonder this place is considered one of the best Italian restaurants in New Braunfels. So, don't hesitate to give it a try and make sure to grab one of those $5 margaritas for the ultimate experience.

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurant in San Antonio.

Di's Homemade Pizza

Highlights
Amazing Pizza
Homemade by Di
Great for families

Di's Homemade Pizza is a hidden gem when it comes to Italian cuisine in New Braunfels. As soon as you step foot into the restaurant, the aroma of freshly baked pizza hits you, instantly whetting your appetite. One of the highlights of this place is undoubtedly their amazing pizza.

What sets Di's Homemade Pizza apart is that it is truly homemade. Being made by Di himself, you can taste the love and dedication that goes into each pizza. The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside, providing a satisfying texture with every bite. The variety of toppings available is also impressive, ensuring that there's something for everyone's taste.

Another reason why Di's Homemade Pizza stands out is its family-friendly atmosphere. The spacious seating area welcomes families with open arms. Children can enjoy the colorful decorations and the option to create their own mini pizzas, making it a fun and interactive experience for them.

Furthermore, the service at Di's Homemade Pizza is top-notch. The staff is attentive, warm, and knowledgeable, always happy to recommend their personal favorites or answer any questions one might have.

Overall, whether you're craving a traditional Margherita or a unique combination of toppings, Di's Homemade Pizza is the place to go. The amazing pizza, the love that goes into each homemade creation, and the family-friendly atmosphere make it a standout choice among the Italian restaurants in New Braunfels. Don't miss out on this delightful culinary experience!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in San Antonio.

Cicis Pizza

Highlights
Good food
Friendly and polite staff
Crustless pizza option
Great service
Clean and bright atmosphere

First of all, let me start by saying that Cicis Pizza is not your average Italian restaurant. It's a place where you can enjoy good food while having a playful and casual dining experience. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and polite staff, who made me feel like a valued guest.

One of the things that stood out to me about Cicis Pizza was their crustless pizza option. Being someone who enjoys the toppings more than the crust, this was a dream come true. I was able to pile my plate high with a variety of delicious toppings without feeling guilty about leaving any crust behind.

Aside from the unique crustless option, the food itself was top-notch. The selection was vast, with different types of pizza, pasta, and salads to choose from. Each bite was bursting with flavor, and every dish seemed to be made with care.

What impressed me the most, though, was the great service. Despite the high number of customers, the staff managed to keep the buffet well-stocked and the tables clean. They were always attentive and quick to refill drinks or bring out freshly-baked pizzas.

The overall atmosphere of Cicis Pizza was clean and bright, making it an enjoyable place to dine. Whether you're visiting with family, friends, or on your own, it's a relaxed environment that allows you to indulge in all the pizza you can eat.

If you're looking for a unique and playful take on Italian cuisine, Cicis Pizza in New Braunfels is definitely worth a visit. The combination of good food, friendly staff, and a clean atmosphere make it a standout option.

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in San Antonio.

Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers New Braunfels

Highlights
Fresh and delicious food
Affordable prices
Great lunch specials
Kid-friendly arcade games

Let me start by saying that Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers may not be your typical Italian restaurant, but don't let that deter you. This hidden gem has some unexpected surprises up its sleeves.

One of the highlights of my visit was the fresh and delicious food. From their hand-tossed pizzas to their mouthwatering pastas, every bite was a burst of flavor. The ingredients were high-quality, and you could tell that they took pride in their cooking.

Besides the amazing food, another aspect that caught my attention was the affordable prices. In a world where dining out can break the bank, Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers offers a welcome relief with their reasonable prices. It's an ideal spot for a budget-friendly family dinner or an impromptu meal with friends.

If you're looking for a great deal, make sure to check out their lunch specials. The value for money is simply unbeatable. Plus, they serve their food with a smile and attentive service.

What also sets Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers apart is its kid-friendly arcade games. This makes it the perfect spot for families, where parents can enjoy a delicious Italian meal while the little ones have a blast playing games.

In conclusion, while Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers New Braunfels may not fit the traditional Italian restaurant mold, their commitment to serving fresh, delicious food at affordable prices, along with their kid-friendly atmosphere, make them a strong contender for the title of the best Italian restaurant in New Braunfels.

You might also want to check out the best patio restaurants in San Antonio.

Villanovas pizza

Villanovas pizza in New Braunfels is a delightful surprise! With its mouthwatering pizza options bursting with flavor, this place has definitely earned a spot on the list of the best Italian restaurants in town. Their crust is perfectly crispy and the toppings are out of this world. Give it a try and you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best korean restaurant in San Antonio.

MOD Pizza

Let me begin by saying that MOD Pizza is a fantastic place to grab a delicious slice. While it may not be strictly Italian, it definitely has the spirit. The playful atmosphere and friendly staff make for a great dining experience. Plus, the customizable pizzas are a dream come true for any foodie. So, while we may not have found the best Italian spot here, MOD Pizza sure knows how to deliver a tasty pie with a smile!

You might also want to check out the best healthy restaurants in San Antonio.

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza in New Braunfels is a delightful surprise for pizza lovers. Their unique concept of taking home a freshly made pizza to bake yourself is genius. The toppings are fresh, the crust is perfectly crisp, and the flavors are magnifico. It's a fun and flavorful way to enjoy a slice of Italia.

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in New Braunfels.

Calahan's Pub and Pizza

Calahan's Pub and Pizza is a hidden gem in New Braunfels, offering a playful twist on traditional Italian cuisine. The pizzas are divine, with their crispy crusts and ooey-gooey cheese. And don't even get me started on their homemade pasta dishes – delizioso! This charming pub truly captures the essence of Italian flavors in a playful and professional manner. Calahan's Pub and Pizza is definitely a strong contender for the title of the best Italian restaurant in New Braunfels.

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in San Antonio.

Marco Polo Cheesesteaks, Subs, and Paninis

This lively spot boasts delicious Italian subs and paninis that will transport your taste buds to the heart of Italy. Every bite is a delightful adventure, with the flavors bursting in your mouth. The staff is exceptionally friendly, adding a warm and welcoming touch to the already cozy atmosphere. I highly recommend trying their signature Marco Polo Cheesesteak, a true masterpiece. Each ingredient is carefully selected and assembled to create a symphony of flavors. Whether you're a fan of cheesesteaks, subs, or paninis, this place has something for everyone. Overall, Marco Polo is a hidden gem that I consider a strong contender for the title of the best Italian restaurant in New Braunfels.

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurant in San Antonio.