New Braunfels' Best Dessert [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed 15 incredible options, I can confidently say that New Braunfels is a dessert lover's paradise.

From classic treats to innovative creations, each place tells its own unique story through flavors and textures.

Join me on this sweet journey as we explore diverse offerings, from beloved local bakeries to hidden gems.

Each bite will transport you to a new level of indulgence, showcasing why this charming town is a must-visit for dessert enthusiasts.

So, grab your forks and prepare for a delectable adventure through the sweetest spots in New Braunfels!

Tipsy Cow Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique boozy ice cream flavors
High-quality ingredients
Creamy, smooth texture
Delicately balanced sweetness
Delicious waffle cones

At Tipsy Cow Ice Cream, the word "ordinary" seems to have been banished altogether. Stepping into this delightful haven, I was instantly captivated by their unique boozy ice cream flavors. Imagine an indulgent scoop infused with your favorite spirit—what’s not to love? The moment I took a bite, I was enveloped by a creamy, smooth texture that danced across my taste buds, leaving me wanting more.

What sets Tipsy Cow apart is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients. Each scoop strikes the perfect balance of sweetness, ensuring that no flavor overpowers the others. I couldn't resist trying their decadent waffle cone, which added an extra layer of delight—a crunchy contrast to the rich ice cream.

I savored each moment, relishing the creative combinations that felt both whimsical and sophisticated. It's a friendly reminder that dessert can be a playful experience while maintaining a sense of elegance. Tipsy Cow Ice Cream has certainly earned its place among the best dessert spots in New Braunfels. If you're looking for a sweet treat with a twist, this is a destination not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in San Antonio.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Light and fluffy Bundt cakes
Options for dietary restrictions
Irresistible flavors available
Returning customers are common

Nothing Bundt Cakes in New Braunfels truly lives up to its name, delivering a delightful experience that left me craving more. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful staff, who instantly made me feel welcome. Their genuine enthusiasm for their treats is palpable, and it adds a personal touch that enhances the whole experience.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the cakes! These light and fluffy Bundt cakes are a heavenly delight. With an array of irresistible flavors to choose from, each bite is a tastebud party. Whether you're a fan of chocolate or you prefer something fruity, they've got you covered. Plus, I was pleasantly surprised to find options for those with dietary restrictions, which is a thoughtful touch that shows they care.

It’s no wonder that returning customers are common here; once you indulge in their sumptuous desserts, you’ll likely be coming back for more. Overall, Nothing Bundt Cakes is a must-visit in New Braunfels for anyone seeking the perfect sweet treat!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Downtown San Antonio.

Marble Slab Creamery

Highlights
Coconut Ice cream
Make your own special
Friendly staff
Peaceful and cheery atmosphere

As I walked through the doors of Marble Slab Creamery, I was enveloped in a truly cheery atmosphere. The peaceful ambiance and friendly staff immediately put me at ease -- it was clear that this place was all about savoring sweet treats and enjoying the moment.

Now, let me tell you about their star attraction – the Coconut Ice Cream. One taste of this creamy delight took me straight to dessert heaven. The coconut flavor was perfectly balanced, and the texture was incredibly smooth. It was like a tropical vacation in a scoop!

Marble Slab Creamery also offers a unique feature that sets it apart from other dessert spots – the ability to make your own special creation! I couldn't resist the opportunity, so I indulged my creative side and crafted a masterpiece. I mixed together a base of their velvety chocolate ice cream and added in chunks of brownie, fudge sauce, and a sprinkle of almonds. The resulting creation was beyond my wildest expectations – pure indulgence in every bite.

But what truly made my experience memorable was the staff. They were not only welcoming but also knowledgeable about their ice cream offerings, and they genuinely seemed to enjoy assisting customers in creating their perfect treat.

So, if you find yourself craving a delectable dessert in New Braunfels, look no further than Marble Slab Creamery. With their delectable Coconut Ice Cream, the option to create your dream dessert, the friendly staff, and the overall charming ambiance, it's no wonder this place is a local favorite. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in San Antonio.

Scoop Street

Highlights
Friendly and kind staff
Creative ice cream flavors
Vegan sorbet options
Variety of vegan drink options

Walking into Scoop Street, I was immediately greeted by the friendly and kind staff who were more than happy to help me navigate the array of delicious desserts on offer. The cheerful atmosphere of the shop set the stage for what turned out to be a delightful dessert experience.

One of the things that impressed me the most about Scoop Street was their creativity when it came to ice cream flavors. From classics like chocolate and vanilla to more adventurous options like lavender honey and spicy mango, they truly pushed the boundaries of traditional flavors. Each scoop was a burst of unique and delicious combinations.

What also stood out at Scoop Street was their commitment to offering options for everyone, regardless of dietary restrictions. As a vegan myself, I was thrilled to find a variety of vegan sorbet options. The raspberry sorbet was tangy and refreshing, and the coconut sorbet had a creamy texture that was simply divine.

In addition to their sorbet selection, Scoop Street also had a variety of vegan drink options to complement their desserts. I highly recommend trying their almond milk cappuccino paired with their vegan chocolates.

Overall, Scoop Street is a must-visit destination for dessert lovers in New Braunfels. The friendly staff, the creative flavors, and the vegan options make it a standout in the dessert scene. So, if you're looking for a scrumptious dessert experience that caters to different palates, do yourself a favor and head over to Scoop Street – your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best fast food burger in San Antonio.

2tarts Bakery

Highlights
Fun and cute coffee shop
Excellent customer service
Delicious and beautifully designed cakes

From the moment I stepped into this fun and cute coffee shop, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was vibrant and cozy, with colorful decor that instantly put a smile on my face. But it wasn't just the aesthetics that impressed me; it was the excellent customer service that truly made my visit memorable.

As I perused the display of desserts, my taste buds danced with anticipation. The selection was vast, but one thing was consistent - each dessert was a work of art. From the delicate pastries to the decadent cupcakes, it was clear that the bakers at 2tarts Bakery poured their heart and soul into their creations.

I couldn't resist trying one of their delicious and beautifully designed cakes. The slice was sheer perfection; moist, fluffy, and bursting with flavor. The generous layer of frosting was smooth as silk and balanced the sweetness of the cake flawlessly.

But 2tarts Bakery doesn't just excel in their cake-making skills. Their desserts catered to every preference, from gluten-free options to vegan treats that tasted just as heavenly as their traditional counterparts.

As I indulged in my delightful dessert, I couldn't help but admire the passion and expertise that went into each bite. 2tarts Bakery truly embodies the essence of a top-tier dessert destination in New Braunfels. Whether you have a sweet tooth or simply appreciate the beauty of a well-crafted dessert, this charming bakery will leave you craving more. Don't miss out on experiencing the magic of 2tarts Bakery for yourself

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX

Highlights
Homemade waffle cones
Great flavor variety
Friendly and kind staff

Upon entering the charming little shop, I was immediately greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked waffle cones. The sight of the homemade cones being meticulously crafted behind the counter filled me with anticipation for the dessert delights that awaited.

The menu at Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX did not disappoint, boasting a spectacular range of flavors. From classic favorites like rich chocolate and creamy vanilla to exotic creations like lavender honey and toasted marshmallow, there was truly something for everyone's taste buds. With so many options available, making a decision was a deliciously difficult task.

As I eagerly awaited my chosen flavors, I couldn't help but notice the warmth and friendliness of the staff. The folks behind the counter were genuinely kind and helpful, ensuring that every customer left with a smile on their face.

Finally, it was time to dig in. With each spoonful, I was transported to dessert heaven. The ice cream was silky smooth, the flavors bursting with intensity, and the homemade waffle cones added a delightful crunch to every bite.

My visit to Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX was a true culinary delight. The combination of the homemade waffle cones, the great flavor variety, and the friendly and kind staff made for an exceptional dessert experience. If you find yourself in New Braunfels, do yourself a favor and indulge in the delectable treats at Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX. Your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Baskin-Robbins

Highlights
Creative custom cakes
Friendly staff
Fantastic ice cream

Entering the quaint little shop, I was immediately greeted with a burst of vibrant colors and a symphony of enticing aromas. The display case was a mesmerizing sight, showcasing a delightful assortment of frozen goodness. It was clear from the start that these folks take their dessert craft seriously.

The friendly staff behind the counter wore cheerful smiles and were more than happy to assist me in making my difficult choice. Their knowledge of the flavors and willingness to offer samples only added to the genuine experience.

Now, let me tell you about the ice cream itself. It was like a little bite of heaven! Each flavor was incredibly creamy, with a fantastic depth of flavor that left me utterly spoiled for choice. From classics like Mint Chocolate Chip to unique creations like Cotton Candy Explosion, there was something to please every palate.

But it wasn't just the standard selection that set Baskin-Robbins apart. Their creative custom cakes were truly a sight to behold. I witnessed the artistry that went into designing these delectable delights, making each cake a centerpiece for any celebration.

Ultimately, my experience at Baskin-Robbins in New Braunfels was a delightful one. The friendly staff and the sheer range of fantastic ice cream flavors make this place a true standout in the dessert scene. If you're in New Braunfels and find yourself craving a sweet treat, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene

Highlights
Fresh and interesting flavors
Homemade taste
Unique and delicious flavors
Worth the trip to Gruene
Wonderful way to spend the day

Let me tell you, this place is an absolute delight for any dessert lover! From the moment I stepped inside, I could smell the sweet aroma of freshly made ice cream wafting through the air. The variety of flavors they offer is simply mind-boggling - they have everything from classic favorites like chocolate and strawberry to more adventurous options like lavender honey and lemon ginger.

What really sets Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene apart is the fact that their ice cream has that homemade taste. You can tell that each batch is carefully crafted with love and attention to detail. Every single scoop is creamy and indulgent, making it a true treat for your taste buds.

The unique and delicious flavors are the stars of the show here. I was blown away by their innovative combination of ingredients. The sweet and tangy flavor of the lemon ginger ice cream was a revelation, and the lavender honey was like a dream in a cone.

If you're visiting New Braunfels, a trip to Gruene to try Rhea's Ice Cream is definitely worth it. It's a wonderful way to spend the day - strolling through the charming streets of Gruene, exploring the boutique shops, and then finding yourself at Rhea's, treating yourself to a scoop (or two!) of their amazing ice cream.

In my quest to find the best dessert in New Braunfels, Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene has certainly left a lasting impression on me. So, do yourself a favor and indulge in the magical flavors they offer. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Naegelin's German Bakery

Highlights
Military discount
Popular with locals and visitors
Doughnut breakfast sandwich
Oldest recipe: bear claw
Wide selection of European pastries

As soon as I stepped into Naegelin's German Bakery, I knew I was in for a sweet treat. The smell of freshly baked pastries wafted through the air, beckoning me closer to the display cases filled with an enticing array of desserts.

One of the first things that caught my attention was the friendly staff and their commitment to customer satisfaction. Not only did they offer a military discount, but they were also quick to serve and answer any questions I had. It was clear that this bakery was not only popular with locals but also with tourists visiting New Braunfels.

I decided to start my dessert adventure with their famous doughnut breakfast sandwich. The combination of the soft, sugary doughnut bun with the savory bacon and eggs was a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was a unique twist on a classic breakfast item.

As I continued my exploration of Naegelin's, I couldn't resist trying their bear claw, one of the oldest recipes in the bakery. The buttery, flaky pastry filled with a rich almond paste was a true delight. It was a testament to the bakery's commitment to preserving traditional European flavors.

What impressed me most about Naegelin's was their wide selection of European pastries. From delicate macarons to indulgent strudels, there was something for every dessert lover. Each treat I sampled was made with exceptional attention to detail, resulting in a perfect balance of flavors and textures.

In conclusion, Naegelin's German Bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. With their military discount, friendly staff, and delectable treats, it's no wonder they have remained a favorite among locals and visitors alike. So, if you find yourself in New Braunfels, make sure to stop by Naegelin's and indulge in the unforgettable desserts they have to offer!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

Sophia's Sweets and Treats

Highlights
Heavenly Funnel Cakes
Variety of Snacks
Great Customer Service
Flavorful Pretzels
Assorted Flavored Funnel Cakes

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and a tantalizing aroma that filled the air. The menu boasted an impressive array of delights, but the Heavenly Funnel Cakes caught my eye. I ordered one with a twist - a drizzle of caramel sauce and a dash of cinnamon. It was a dessert fit for the gods!

But let me tell you, Sophia's Sweets and Treats offers so much more than just funnel cakes. Their selection of snacks is truly impressive. From flavorful pretzels to a variety of other sweet treats, every craving is sure to be satisfied.

What truly sets Sophia's apart, though, is their commitment to great customer service. The staff was knowledgeable and friendly, eager to provide recommendations based on my preferences. It made the whole experience feel personal and special.

As I sunk my teeth into my pastry masterpiece, I was overwhelmed with the explosion of flavors dancing on my tongue. The funnel cake was insanely delicious with every bite showcasing the perfect balance of sweetness and indulgence. It was no wonder they offered a variety of assorted flavored funnel cakes, they truly know how to take a classic dessert and elevate it to new heights.

In conclusion, Sophia's Sweets and Treats is a dessert haven that cannot be missed. Their heavenly funnel cakes, variety of snacks, and remarkable customer service make it the go-to place for anyone seeking the best dessert in New Braunfels. So, don't just meet your cravings, exceed them with a visit to Sophia's.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels

Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels in New Braunfels is a tropical paradise for your taste buds. Their shaved ice creations are anything but ordinary. With a splash of their flavorful syrups and a dip in their secret ingredient, you'll be transported to dessert heaven. Prepare for a sweet adventure at Bahama Buck's!

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

New City Bakery

New City Bakery in New Braunfels is a hidden gem for all dessert lovers! Their treats are a culinary masterpiece that will transport your taste buds into bliss. From the decadent cakes to the flaky pastries, every bite is pure scrumptious delight. Don't miss out on this sweet sensation!

You might also want to check out the best steak in San Antonio.

Sweet Bites by Lizzie

Let me tell you, Sweet Bites by Lizzie is like stepping into a flavor wonderland. From the moment you walk through the door, you'll be greeted by the intoxicating scent of freshly baked treats. And trust me, the taste lives up to the aroma. Their cupcakes are the stuff of dreams, with light, fluffy cake and creamy, decadent frosting that will make your taste buds dance with joy. But it doesn't stop there. Their cookies are divine, with a perfect combination of chewy and crispy textures that will leave you wanting more. And if you're looking for something cold and refreshing, their ice cream is a must-try. Creamy, smooth, and bursting with flavor, it's the perfect treat on a hot day. Trust me, you won't be disappointed with your visit to Sweet Bites by Lizzie. So grab your friends, your appetite, and get ready for a sweet adventure you won't forget.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast tacos in San Antonio.

Paleteria La Reina

Oh, what a treat! Paleteria La Reina in New Braunfels is a delightful oasis of frozen goodness. The vibrant colors and mouth-watering flavors of their handmade paletas are a sight to behold. From classic favorites like strawberry and mango, to unique creations like avocado and tamarind, there's a paleta for every palate. The taste is pure bliss, with a perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess. Whether you're a child or an adult, Paleteria La Reina will make you feel like a kid in a candy store. Don't miss out on this gem when exploring the best desserts in New Braunfels!

You might also want to check out the best tamales in San Antonio.

Great American Cookies

Great American Cookies in New Braunfels is a dessert paradise, with their delicious and decadent treats stealing the show. From their ooey-gooey chocolate chip cookies to their dreamy cookie cakes, every bite is a celebration. It's safe to say that this place deserves a sweet spot in the best dessert in New Braunfels list!