Schertz's Best Pizza [Updated 2024]

From crispy thin crusts to gooey cheese and mouthwatering toppings, the pizzerias in Schertz have it all. With a belly full of pizza from countless taste tests, I am confident in sharing my top picks with you.

After reviewing a whopping 15 pizza places in the area, I have narrowed down the absolute best. So, whether you're a local looking to indulge or a visitor seeking the tastiest slice, join me on this lighthearted journey to find the best pizza Schertz has to offer.

Let's dig in!

Mattenga's Pizzeria

Highlights
Brisket pizza
Friendly staff
Reasonable prices
Amazing pizza
Superb customer service

Upon entering Mattenga's Pizzeria, I was immediately greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza. The atmosphere was relaxed and cozy, with a touch of rustic charm. The friendly staff welcomed me with warm smiles, making me feel right at home.

As an adventurous pizza connoisseur, I couldn't resist trying their famous brisket pizza. Let me tell you, it was a flavor explosion! The combination of tender, smoky brisket, tangy barbecue sauce, and melty cheese was a match made in pizza heaven. Each bite was a symphony of savory goodness that left me craving more.

Not only was their pizza amazing, but the prices were also reasonable. They offer great value for the quality and portion sizes they provide. Mattenga's Pizzeria has truly mastered the art of balancing taste and affordability.

What impressed me the most, however, was the superb customer service. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that all my needs were met. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their craft. It was evident that they take pride in delivering a memorable dining experience.

Overall, my visit to Mattenga's Pizzeria was a delightful journey for my taste buds. With their irresistible brisket pizza, friendly staff, reasonable prices, and superb customer service, it's no wonder they are a top contender for the title of the best pizza in Schertz. I highly recommend paying them a visit and indulging in their pizza perfection.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Downtown San Antonio.

Pizzeria Mia Marco's

Highlights
Crispy crust
Flavorful sauce
Quality cheese
Homestyle taste

Upon entering Pizzeria Mia Marco's, I was instantly greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, making my mouth water in anticipation.

As I sat down, I couldn't help but notice the crispy crust on the pizzas being served to other customers. It was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crunch. Each bite gave a delightful snap, making me savor every mouthful.

The flavor of the sauce was exceptional. It had a robust and tangy taste that complemented the toppings beautifully. The sauce was generously spread, providing a burst of deliciousness in every bite. It was evident that the chefs at Pizzeria Mia Marco's took great care in crafting their sauce.

The quality of the cheese was evident in every slice. It was wonderfully melted and had a rich and creamy texture. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, with the cheese adding a delightful richness to the overall taste.

What set Pizzeria Mia Marco's apart was the homestyle taste of their pizzas. It felt like I was enjoying a slice of heaven right at home. The combination of the fresh ingredients, crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and quality cheese made for an unforgettable pizza experience.

In my quest to find the best pizza in Schertz, Pizzeria Mia Marco's impressed me with their crispy crust, flavorful sauce, quality cheese, and homestyle taste. It's no wonder this establishment has garnered a loyal following. If you're looking for a pizza that will satisfy your cravings, look no further than Pizzeria Mia Marco's.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in New Braunfels.

Schlotzsky's

Highlights
Hot fresh sourdough bread
Loaded Baked Potato Soup
The Original sandwich
Clean and spacious location
Delicious food and desserts

Let me start by saying that this place is more than just another pizza joint. As soon as I walked in, the smell of hot fresh sourdough bread greeted me, instantly setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.

After perusing the menu, I decided to start with their renowned Loaded Baked Potato Soup, and boy, was I impressed! It was creamy, savory, and packed with all the flavors of a loaded baked potato.

Now, let's talk about their pizzas. While Schlotzsky's is famous for their sandwiches, their pizzas are definitely not to be overlooked. I opted for their classic The Original pizza. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the combination of toppings, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, and black olives, was simply mouthwatering. Each bite was a flavorful explosion that left me craving for more.

One thing that stood out about this Schlotzsky's location was its cleanliness and spaciousness. Unlike some cramped eateries, Schlotzsky's provided me with a comfortable and inviting atmosphere to enjoy my meal.

Before leaving, I couldn't resist indulging in one of their delightful desserts. I chose the delicious food and desserts options. The moist and decadent chocolate chip cookie was the perfect sweet ending to this delightful culinary journey.

In conclusion, if you're in Schertz and looking for some playfully delicious pizzas, Schlotzsky's is definitely worth a visit. With their hot fresh sourdough bread, savory soups, delectable pizzas, and inviting atmosphere, this place has all the ingredients to be considered among the best pizza spots in Schertz.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in San Antonio.

Big Papa's Pizza & Sports

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Homewrecker is a favorite
Good service
Reasonable prices

Walking into Big Papa's Pizza & Sports, my senses were immediately captivated by the tantalizing aroma of delicious pizza wafting through the air. The place had a lively and energetic atmosphere, perfect for sports enthusiasts and pizza lovers alike.

As a pizza connoisseur, I tend to seek out unique and out-of-the-box flavors. Big Papa's did not disappoint. Their signature pizza, the "Homewrecker," stole my heart (and taste buds). This marvelous creation was piled high with a delightful combination of fresh toppings and gooey cheese, leaving me craving for more with every bite. The flavors danced across my palate, making it nearly impossible to resist another slice.

Apart from the exceptional pizza, the service at Big Papa's was top-notch. The staff members were friendly, attentive, and ensured that I had everything I needed to enjoy my dining experience. Their knowledge and enthusiasm about pizzas were clearly evident, and they were more than happy to assist me in choosing from their extensive selection of flavors.

What's even more appealing about Big Papa's is their commitment to providing quality food at reasonable prices. It's a place where you can indulge in scrumptious pizzas without breaking the bank.

In conclusion, Big Papa's Pizza & Sports has undoubtedly earned its place on the list of the best pizzas in Schertz. With their mouthwatering creations, friendly service, and affordable prices, it's a must-visit spot for any pizza lover. Whether you're looking for a classic favorite or an adventurous flavor combination, Big Papa's is sure to fulfill your cravings and leave you wanting more.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

Pizza Hut

Highlights
Fast and efficient service
Good quality food
Friendly and professional staff
Limited time deep dish pizza
Family favorite

First and foremost, I was impressed by the fast and efficient service at Pizza Hut in Schertz. My order was taken promptly, and I didn't have to wait long for my pizza to arrive at the table.

Speaking of the pizza, I must say that the quality of the food was impressive. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside, just the way I like it. The sauce had a tangy and flavorful kick that left me craving for more. The toppings were generous and cooked to perfection, providing a burst of flavors in every bite.

The friendly and professional staff at Pizza Hut in Schertz added to the overall wonderful experience. They were attentive and accommodating, making sure we had everything we needed throughout our meal.

I was delighted to discover that they had a limited time deep dish pizza on their menu. As a pizza enthusiast, I couldn't resist the temptation and decided to give it a try. Let me tell you, it didn't disappoint! The deep dish crust was thick and buttery, providing a delightful contrast to the savory cheese and toppings.

Pizza Hut in Schertz is definitely a family favorite. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making it a great place for a family outing. The kids will love the ample space to run around, and the adults can enjoy a slice of delicious pizza and engage in lively conversation.

In conclusion, Pizza Hut in Schertz is a must-visit for pizza lovers. With its fast and efficient service, good quality food, friendly staff, limited time deep dish pizza, and family-friendly atmosphere, it truly stands out as one of the best pizza places in Schertz.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Domino's Pizza

Highlights
Loved the online experience!
Quick service
Friendly staff
Quality food
Never had a mistake

Let's start with the online experience. It was phenomenal! Ordering was a breeze, and the website was designed with the customer in mind. I loved how user-friendly it was, making it easy to customize my pizza just the way I wanted it. Plus, the option to track my order in real time was an exciting feature that kept my anticipation building.

Upon arrival, I was pleasantly surprised by the quick service. Not only was my pizza ready on time, but the staff also managed to be friendly and engaging, making the overall experience even more enjoyable. It's refreshing to see that great service still exists in an age of expedited consumerism.

Now let's talk about the food itself. Oh boy, was I blown away by the quality! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside, yet delightfully soft on the inside. The sauce was rich and tangy, while the cheese was gooey and melted to perfection. Topped with fresh ingredients, each bite delivered a burst of flavor that left me wanting more.

What truly impressed me was that I've never encountered a single mistake with my order at Domino's Pizza in Schertz. Everything was always exactly as I had ordered, which is a rarity in the pizza world. It demonstrates the attention to detail and dedication to customer satisfaction that sets this place apart.

In conclusion, Domino's Pizza in Schertz gave me an unforgettable dining experience. From the seamless online ordering process to the fast and friendly service, and most importantly, the exceptional taste and quality of the pizza itself, this place gets my wholehearted recommendation. Don't miss out on a slice of heaven when you're craving a delicious pizza in Schertz!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

Papa Johns Pizza

Highlights
Great staff
Fresh pizza
Timely delivery
Excellent customer service

Let's start with the highlights of this place. First, I must mention the great staff at Papa Johns. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm smiles and a helpful attitude. They truly know how to make their customers feel appreciated.

Now let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Papa Johns is known for using only the freshest ingredients, and boy, does it show! Each bite of their pizza was bursting with flavor, from the tangy tomato sauce to the perfectly melted cheese. The crust had just the right balance of chewiness and crispiness, making it simply delightful.

One thing I must commend Papa Johns on is their timely delivery. As a busy writer, I often find myself short on time, so having my pizza arrive promptly is a priority. I was pleasantly surprised when my order arrived at my doorstep right on schedule. It's clear that Papa Johns values their customers' time.

Lastly, I must give a special shoutout to the excellent customer service I received at this location. The friendly staff not only ensured that my order was correct, but they also went above and beyond to accommodate any special requests I had.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a pizza joint in Schertz that doesn't disappoint, Papa Johns Pizza is the place to go. With their amazing staff, fresh ingredients, timely delivery, and impeccable customer service, it's no wonder they're considered one of the best in town.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Little Caesars Pizza

Highlights
Fresh Food
Good Service
Fast Service
Parking

I must say, Little Caesars Pizza in Schertz definitely left a lasting impression on me. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly smile. The staff was attentive and provided exceptional service throughout my visit.

First and foremost, the freshness of the food at Little Caesars Pizza was undeniable. The ingredients were of high quality, and the flavors were authentic and delicious. Whether it was the tangy sauce, the perfect blend of cheeses, or the flavorful toppings, each bite was a delightful explosion of taste.

One aspect that really stood out to me was the speed at which my order was prepared. Little Caesars Pizza in Schertz definitely lives up to its reputation of providing fast service. Despite the rush of customers, my pizza was promptly prepared, allowing me to indulge in this culinary delight without any unnecessary waiting.

Moreover, the parking situation was convenient, making it easy for me to access the restaurant. It's always a pleasant surprise when finding parking in a busy area, so kudos to Little Caesars Pizza for taking that into consideration.

In conclusion, Little Caesars Pizza in Schertz embodies the perfect trifecta of freshness, good service, and fast service. As a pizza connoisseur, I highly recommend giving this place a visit when you're in Schertz. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

Marco's Pizza

Highlights
Delicious crust
Picture perfect pizzas
Good & cheesy mozzarella
Fresh toppings
Great atmosphere

Walking into Marco's Pizza, I was immediately greeted by a great atmosphere. The cozy and inviting ambiance made me feel right at home. As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the picture perfect pizzas being served to each table. They were a feast for the eyes!

After much contemplation, I decided on a classic cheese pizza. One bite into the delicious crust, and I knew I had made the right choice. It was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The crust held up well to the weight of the fresh and flavorful toppings.

Speaking of toppings, the mozzarella on the pizza was good and cheesy. Each bite was a melty delight! And speaking of the toppings, they were fresh and bursting with flavor. From the tangy tomatoes to the savory pepperoni, every ingredient worked together harmoniously.

The service at Marco's Pizza was top-notch. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed throughout my meal. I appreciated the attention to detail and the genuine care they provided.

In conclusion, Marco's Pizza in Schertz is a true gem. With its delicious crust, picture perfect pizzas, good and cheesy mozzarella, fresh toppings, and great atmosphere, it's no wonder why it's considered one of the best pizza places in town. If you're a pizza lover like me, you definitely don't want to miss out on this amazing pizzeria.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Catalano's Pizzeria

Highlights
Homemade dishes with great prices
Perfectly breaded chicken Parmesan
Light and fresh focaccia bread
Made from scratch and packed with flavor
Very friendly staff

As soon as I walked into Catalano's, I was greeted by a friendly staff that made me feel right at home. And let me tell you, the homemade dishes they serve are truly a game-changer in the Schertz pizza scene.

One of the highlights at Catalano's is their perfectly breaded chicken Parmesan. The chicken was tender and juicy, while the breadcrumbs added a satisfying crunch. Each bite was a delightful combination of flavors.

I also had the pleasure of trying their light and fresh focaccia bread. It was warm and airy, with a subtle herb seasoning that elevated the taste to the next level. I couldn't resist having more than one slice!

What sets Catalano's apart from the rest is their commitment to making everything from scratch. You can taste it in every bite. The pizza dough was light and crispy, while the tomato sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. It was truly a symphony of flavors.

Not only was the food outstanding, but Catalano's also offers great prices. You can enjoy a delicious meal without breaking the bank. It's a win-win situation!

All in all, Catalano's Pizzeria in Schertz is a hidden gem. From the homemade dishes to the friendly staff, it's a place that deserves to be on the list of the best pizza spots in Schertz. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their irresistible delights!

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Anchor Bar

It was an absolute delight to discover Anchor Bar in Schertz during my quest for the best pizza in town. The playful yet professional ambiance immediately caught my attention, setting the stage for a memorable culinary experience. The pizzas, oh the pizzas, were the true stars. Each slice was a work of art, expertly crafted with a perfect balance of flavors. The crust was thin, yet delightfully crispy, and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. I must commend them on their diverse menu, offering a variety of unique pizzas that cater to every palate. The service was efficient and friendly, ensuring that my dining experience was top-notch. Anchor Bar undoubtedly earns a spot on the list of the best pizzas in Schertz.

You might also want to check out the best steak in San Antonio.

Capparelli's Italian Food, Pizza, & Catering

Capparelli's Italian Food, Pizza, & Catering in Schertz is a delightful haven for pizza lovers. Their wood-fired crust is simply perfection. With a wide array of toppings to choose from and a generous amount of cheese, each bite is a flavorful adventure. Don't forget to try their homemade marinara sauce for an extra burst of mouthwatering goodness.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast tacos in San Antonio.

46th st. New York Style Pizzeria

46th St. New York Style Pizzeria in Schertz is a pizza lover's paradise! With its thin crust, fresh ingredients, and authentic New York flavors, this pizzeria is a must-visit. The cheese is gooey, the sauce is tangy, and the toppings are plentiful. Don't miss out on their mouthwatering pepperoni slices or their flavor-packed margherita pizza. Whether you're a native New Yorker or a pizza enthusiast, this place will not disappoint.

You might also want to check out the best tamales in San Antonio.

Mr Gatti's Pizza Universal City

After indulging in a slice-filled odyssey across Schertz, I can confidently say that Mr Gatti's Pizza Universal City is a gem in the pizza-scape. Their crust is divinely chewy and their toppings are abundantly flavorful. With each bite, my taste buds danced in ecstasy. This joint definitely deserves a spot on the best pizza in Schertz list.

Rapid Fired Pizza

Rapid Fired Pizza in Schertz is a delightful pizzeria that caters to both traditional and adventurous palates. With their unique and speedy build-your-own pizza concept, customers can choose from an array of fresh toppings and watch as their masterpiece is rapidly fired to perfection in the oven. The crust is thin and crispy, allowing the flavors to shine. Their sauce is the real star, bursting with tanginess and just the right amount of zest. The generous amount of cheese melts perfectly on top, forming a golden blanket that seals in the flavors. The staff at Rapid Fired Pizza is friendly and attentive, providing a pleasant and efficient dining experience. Whether you prefer classics like pepperoni or prefer to venture into more gourmet toppings, Rapid Fired Pizza in Schertz is a must-try for any pizza lover looking for fast, delicious, and customizable pies.