New Braunfels' Best Ice Cream [Updated 2024]

From classic flavors to innovative creations, this charming Texas town is home to a variety of delightful ice cream shops.

Over the past few weeks, I've visited 15 of them, tasting everything from gooey caramel swirls to refreshing fruit sorbets.

Each scoop tells a story, not just of the ingredients, but of the passion put into making these delectable treats.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, I'm excited to share my top picks that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth!

Tipsy Cow Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique alcohol-infused flavors
Rich, creamy, smooth texture
Exceptional quality ingredients
Delicious non-alcohol options
Friendly after-dinner spot

Tipsy Cow Ice Cream in New Braunfels is a delightful twist on the classic ice cream experience. As I walked through the door, I was greeted with a vibrant atmosphere that perfectly matched the playful spirit of their offerings. My excitement peaked as I scanned their unique selection of alcohol-infused flavors. Being bold, I chose the Salted Caramel Bourbon. With each spoonful, I reveled in the rich and creamy texture that danced on my palate, showcasing the quality ingredients that they clearly prioritize.

But don’t let the alcohol options overshadow their equally tempting non-alcoholic delights. My friend opted for the Triple Chocolate Fudge, and I must say—it was a chocolate lover’s dream; rich without being overly sweet.

What struck me most was how the shop serves as an ideal after-dinner spot to unwind. The friendly staff illuminated the space with their enthusiasm, making it even more enjoyable. Overall, Tipsy Cow Ice Cream is not just about ice cream; it's about creating memorable moments. I left with a smile, knowing I’d found another contender in my quest for the best ice cream in New Braunfels. Indulge yourself here; it’s worth every scoop!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

The shack

Highlights
Cute place with nice owner
Excellent flavor selection
Quick and awesome service
Generously sized snow cones

The Shack in New Braunfels is a delightful little gem that immediately won my heart. As I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly owner, whose passion for ice cream is infectious. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, making it the perfect spot to indulge in some sweet treats.

What truly sets The Shack apart is its excellent flavor selection. From classic favorites to unique creations, there's something to entice every palate. I found myself torn between flavors but eventually settled on a scoop of their signature vanilla bean sprinkled with a hint of cinnamon — pure bliss!

The service? Quick and awesome! I barely had time to snap some photos before my delicious ice cream was handed to me. And let me tell you about the snow cones; they are generously sized and bursting with flavor, perfect for cooling off on a hot Texas day.

Overall, I highly recommend The Shack for anyone in search of ice cream that’s not just tasty but also served with a smile. Trust me, once you visit, you’ll understand why this charming place is a must-try in New Braunfels!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Highlights
Great flavor
Consistently tasty
Variety of menu choices
Clean and friendly staff

Let's start with the flavor. Oh boy, let me tell you, Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard truly knows how to pack a punch of deliciousness in every scoop. Each bite was a burst of flavor that made me close my eyes and savor the moment.

One thing that impressed me about Rita's was the consistency of their ice cream. Every time I visited, I could count on their ice cream being creamy and smooth, with just the right amount of sweetness. It's like they have some sort of secret recipe that they guard with their lives.

And speaking of options, Rita's boasts a variety of menu choices. Whether you're in the mood for classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla or fancy something a bit more adventurous like cotton candy or mango, Rita's has got you covered. They even have a rotating selection of seasonal flavors to keep things interesting.

I also want to give a shoutout to the clean and friendly staff at Rita's. They always greeted me with a smile and were more than happy to help me navigate through their mouth-watering menu. It just adds to the overall experience and makes you feel welcome.

In conclusion, I confidently recommend Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard as one of the best ice cream spots in New Braunfels. With their outstanding flavors, consistency, variety, and friendly staff, it's an experience you don't want to miss out on. Go ahead, indulge yourself a little. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

New Braunfels Coffee

Highlights
Excellent breakfast
Delicious pastries
Relaxing atmosphere
Free parking
Wheelchair accessible

First of all, let me start by saying that this place serves way more than just coffee. From the moment I walked in, I could tell that New Braunfels Coffee is a delightful spot for an ice cream enthusiast like myself.

What caught my eye were the excellent breakfast options they had, but my heart was truly won over by their irresistible selection of delicious pastries – perfect accompaniments to a creamy scoop or two of ice cream.

The moment I took my first bite of their homemade ice cream, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. The flavors were rich and decadent, and the texture was delightfully smooth. Each bite was like a little taste of heaven.

The relaxing atmosphere of the café made the experience even more enjoyable. With cozy seating and soft music playing in the background, it was a perfect place to savor my ice cream and escape from the outside world, if only for a moment.

Another perk of visiting New Braunfels Coffee is the free parking. This made it incredibly convenient for me to drop by and indulge in their ice cream whenever the mood struck. And, not to mention, the café is wheelchair accessible, making it a place that everyone can enjoy.

In conclusion, New Braunfels Coffee is not just a coffee shop - it’s a hidden gem for ice cream lovers. With their excellent breakfast options, delectable pastries, and heavenly homemade ice cream, it's a must-visit destination for any ice cream enthusiast in New Braunfels. So, if you find yourself craving a sweet treat, don't hesitate to visit New Braunfels Coffee. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX

Highlights
Homemade waffle cones
Interesting flavors
Nostalgic atmosphere
Friendly service

Walking into Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX was like stepping into a time machine. The nostalgic atmosphere made me feel like a kid again, eagerly awaiting a sweet treat. As I approached the counter, the sight of homemade waffle cones being freshly made filled the air with a delightful aroma.

My taste buds were in for a treat as I perused the interesting flavors on display. From classic options like creamy vanilla and rich chocolate to unique creations like lavender honey and jalapeno lime, there was something to satisfy every craving. My adventurous side couldn't resist trying the lavender honey, and oh boy, was I in for a delicious surprise. The floral notes combined with the sweetness of honey had me hooked from the first bite.

Not only was the ice cream outstanding, but the friendly service made the experience even more enjoyable. The staff took the time to help me navigate through the array of flavors, offering suggestions and samples along the way.

As I sat outside, enjoying my creamy delight under the Texas sun, I couldn't help but appreciate the care and craftsmanship that goes into Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX's creations. It's clear that they take pride in every scoop they serve.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a trip down memory lane with a twist of playfulness and a dash of creativity, Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX is the place to be. Indulge yourself with their homemade waffle cones, explore their interesting flavors, and let their nostalgic atmosphere transport you to a sweeter time. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

Scoop Street

Highlights
Amazing staff
Deliciously original flavors
Vegan options available

Upon entering Scoop Street, I was immediately greeted by the amazing staff who were not only friendly, but also knowledgeable about their ice cream offerings. They enthusiastically guided me through their extensive menu, which is filled with deliciously original flavors that are sure to tickle your taste buds.

After much deliberation, I finally settled on two scoops: one of their signature flavors, Caramel Crunch, and another of their seasonal flavor, Peach Cobbler. Let me tell you, I was not disappointed. The Caramel Crunch was an explosion of creamy caramel swirled with crunchy bits that added a delightful texture. As for the Peach Cobbler, it was like biting into a slice of warm peach pie. The flavors were both rich and refreshing, leaving me wanting more.

What impressed me even more about Scoop Street is their consideration for different dietary needs. They offer a range of vegan options for those with dietary restrictions or preferences, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their delectable treats.

Overall, my experience at Scoop Street was a delight. The combination of amazing staff, deliciously original flavors, and vegan options make it a standout ice cream shop in New Braunfels. Whether you're a local or just passing through, I highly recommend giving Scoop Street a visit. Prepare yourself for an indulgent ice cream experience that will leave you screaming for more!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Marble Slab Creamery

Highlights
Coconut Ice cream
Make your own special
Friendly staff
Peaceful atmosphere
Great service

Walking into Marble Slab Creamery, I was immediately greeted by a friendly staff ready to help me craft the perfect ice cream creation. The array of flavors available was impressive, but one that caught my attention was the coconut ice cream. It was creamy, rich, and had just the right hint of tropical goodness.

What sets Marble Slab Creamery apart from other ice cream shops is their unique concept of allowing customers to make their own special creations. From choosing the ice cream flavor to selecting mix-ins and toppings, the possibilities are endless. It's like being a kid in a candy store, except this time it's all about ice cream.

As I sat down to enjoy my custom-made ice cream masterpiece, I couldn't help but appreciate the peaceful atmosphere of Marble Slab. The shop had a cozy and inviting ambiance, perfect for indulging in a sweet treat and escaping from the hectic outside world.

To top it all off, the service at Marble Slab Creamery was exceptional. The staff was attentive, making sure my order was made to perfection and answering any questions I had with enthusiasm. It's clear they take pride in providing great service to their customers.

In conclusion, Marble Slab Creamery is a must-visit spot for ice cream lovers in New Braunfels. With their delicious coconut ice cream, the opportunity to make your own unique creation, and the friendly staff, it's no wonder why this place stands out. So, go ahead and treat yourself to a delightful ice cream experience at Marble Slab Creamery, where every spoonful is a journey of flavor and fun.

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene

Highlights
Yummy and fresh flavors
Unique and delicious options
Homemade taste
Amazing and unique flavors
Perfect for a leisurely stroll

Walking into Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene, I was immediately greeted by the scent of fresh waffle cones being made right before my eyes. It was a promising start, and I couldn't wait to dive into the yummy and fresh flavors they had to offer.

One thing that sets Rhea's Ice Cream apart is their commitment to providing unique and delicious options. With flavors like Lavender Honey and Cayenne Chocolate, they truly take ice cream to a whole new level. Each scoop was bursting with flavor, and I found myself savoring every bite.

What really stood out to me was the homemade taste. You could truly taste the passion and love that went into crafting each batch. The ice cream was rich, creamy, and had the perfect balance of sweetness.

Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene is a paradise for ice cream lovers looking for amazing and unique flavors. Whether you're a fan of classics like Mint Chocolate Chip or prefer to venture into more daring combinations, they have something for everyone. It's a place where you can indulge in your favorite ice cream while taking a leisurely stroll through the charming streets of Gruene.

In conclusion, Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene is a hidden gem in New Braunfels. Their commitment to quality and creativity shines through in every scoop. If you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth with a taste of something extraordinary, Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene is the place to be. Don't miss out on this delightful ice cream experience that will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best steak in San Antonio.

Baskin-Robbins

Highlights
Creative ice cream cakes
Friendly staff
Fantastic ice cream

Upon entering Baskin-Robbins, I was immediately greeted with a warm and welcoming smile from the staff. Their friendly demeanor set the tone for what turned out to be a truly delightful ice cream adventure.

The first thing that caught my eye was the impressive selection of creative ice cream cakes. From whimsical designs to elegant creations, Baskin-Robbins showcased their prowess in both taste and presentation. It was evident that they take great care in crafting these masterpieces. Each cake was a visual treat, and I couldn't help but snap a few pictures before indulging in a slice.

But it was the ice cream itself that stole the show. Baskin-Robbins exceeded my expectations with their fantastic flavors. From classics like chocolate and strawberry to more unique options like caramel praline and mint chocolate chip, there was something to satisfy every ice cream lover's craving. Each scoop was a fusion of creamy goodness, sending my taste buds into a frenzy of delight.

What sets Baskin-Robbins apart from other ice cream shops is not only their delectable offerings but also the passion and attention to detail that goes into their creations. Each spoonful was a testament to their dedication towards providing the best ice cream experience possible.

Overall, my visit to Baskin-Robbins in New Braunfels was a delightful and memorable experience. With their creative ice cream cakes, friendly staff, and fantastic ice cream flavors, this place is undeniably one of the best ice cream spots in the city. If you're looking for a playful yet professional ice cream adventure, I highly recommend stopping by Baskin-Robbins in New Braunfels.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast tacos in San Antonio.

Paleteria La Reina

Highlights
Tons of snacks
Friendly service
Fantastic flavors
Reasonable prices
Fresh ingredients

Walking into Paleteria La Reina, I was immediately struck by the vibrant and enticing assortment of ice creams and snacks. There were so many options, it was hard to know where to begin! But rest assured, the friendly staff was there to help guide me through the selection process.

The first thing that caught my eye was the variety of snacks available. From churros to nachos, there was something for everyone. It was the perfect place to indulge in some sweet and savory treats.

Now let's talk about the star of the show – the ice creams. And oh boy, were they fantastic! The flavors were unlike anything I had ever tasted before. From classic options like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous flavors like mango chili and horchata, there was truly something for every palate. Each scoop was bursting with flavor, and it was evident that Paleteria La Reina uses only the freshest ingredients.

What pleasantly surprised me was the reasonable prices. Despite the high quality and diverse range of flavors, the ice creams were very affordable. I enjoyed being able to treat myself without breaking the bank.

Overall, my experience at Paleteria La Reina was nothing short of delightful. The abundance of snacks, friendly service, fantastic flavors, reasonable prices, and use of fresh ingredients truly set this place apart. If you're in New Braunfels and in need of an ice cream fix, I highly recommend giving Paleteria La Reina a visit. It's a place where taste buds come to dance, and ice cream dreams come true.

You might also want to check out the best tamales in San Antonio.

Dairy Queen

Dairy Queen in New Braunfels is a delightful haven for ice cream enthusiasts. With their creamy soft serve and endless topping options, they make sure to satisfy all taste buds. The ooey-gooey hot fudge sundae is a personal favorite of mine, but their Blizzards are what they're truly famous for. Each spoonful is a sweet burst of flavor that will have you coming back for more. The friendly staff and charming atmosphere complete the experience. If you're looking for a sweet treat that will make your taste buds dance, Dairy Queen is the place to be in New Braunfels.

Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels

Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels is an irresistible tropical delight. Their ice cream is an explosion of flavors that transport you to a Caribbean paradise. The extensive menu offers unique and refreshing options that will satisfy any craving. Don't miss out on their signature Bahama Rama Mama or the creamy dreamy Coconut Cream Pie.

Orange Leaf

Orange Leaf in New Braunfels is a playful ice cream haven that delighted my taste buds. With a vast selection of flavors and toppings, each spoonful was a mini adventure. The creamy texture and bold flavors left me craving for more. It truly deserves a spot amongst the best ice cream joints in town.

Pop'topia

Just when I thought I knew all there was to know about ice cream, I stumbled upon Pop'topia, a whimsical wonderland of frozen treats in New Braunfels. With their unique and colorful selection of handcrafted popsicles, I felt like I had entered an ice cream utopia. Each bite was a burst of flavor explosion, and the imaginative combinations left me craving more. If you're looking for an ice cream adventure, don't miss out on Pop'topia in New Braunfels.

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt is a delightful spot for frozen treats in New Braunfels. With their wide range of flavors and toppings, there's something for everyone's taste buds. The tangy and creamy yogurt hits the spot, creating a fun and refreshing experience. You're sure to leave with a smile on your face and a satisfied sweet tooth!