New Braunfels' Best Milkshake [Updated 2024]

When it comes to milkshakes, my taste buds have been on an adventure exploring every nook and cranny of New Braunfels. I have tried and reviewed a whopping 15 milkshake establishments in this charming town, all in search of the creamiest, most delicious concoction to tantalize your taste buds.

So, for all you milkshake enthusiasts out there, get ready to dive into a lighthearted journey to find the absolute best milkshake in New Braunfels. Trust me, this is a sweet treat you don't want to miss!

Tipsy Cow Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique and delicious
Quality ingredients
Perfect balance
Creamy and smooth

Upon stepping into Tipsy Cow Ice Cream, I immediately felt a sense of excitement. The vibrant and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with the delightful aroma of freshly made ice cream, set the stage for what was about to be an extraordinary milkshake experience.

The menu at Tipsy Cow Ice Cream boasted an array of unique and delicious milkshake flavors, making it difficult to choose just one. After much contemplation, I finally settled on their signature "Tipsy Cowshake," a delectable concoction of bourbon-infused vanilla ice cream, caramel swirls, and chunks of buttery pecan.

From the first sip, I was blown away. The milkshake possessed the perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess, with each ingredient shining through. The high-quality ingredients used by Tipsy Cow Ice Cream were evident in every spoonful, delivering a rich and indulgent experience.

What truly sets Tipsy Cow Ice Cream apart is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients, which adds a unique touch to each milkshake. The result is a fresh and unparalleled flavor that is simply unmatched.

The texture of the shake was velvety smooth, making each sip immensely satisfying. It was clear that Tipsy Cow Ice Cream has mastered the art of blending ice cream to perfection.

The staff at Tipsy Cow Ice Cream were friendly and knowledgeable, offering suggestions and ensuring a delightful visit. Whether you're an ice cream aficionado or simply have a sweet tooth, a trip to Tipsy Cow Ice Cream is an absolute must.

In conclusion, Tipsy Cow Ice Cream in New Braunfels is the ultimate destination for milkshake enthusiasts. The unique flavors, quality ingredients, perfect balance, and the creamy and smooth texture make it a standout in the quest for the best milkshake in town. So go ahead and treat yourself to an unforgettable milkshake experience at Tipsy Cow Ice Cream!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

Sonic Drive-In

Highlights
Easy stop
Delicious food
Friendly service
Variety of menu

Let me start by saying that finding the best milkshake can sometimes feel like a quest for the Holy Grail. But fear not, my milkshake-loving friends, because I may have stumbled upon a hidden gem – Sonic Drive-In in New Braunfels.

As I pulled into the parking lot of Sonic, I realized that convenience was on its side. Its location makes it an easy stop for anyone craving a delicious milkshake.

I walked in, greeted by the tantalizing aroma of burgers and fries. But today, my mission was clear - to find the creamiest, most flavorful milkshake in town. I placed my order and within moments, I was presented with a frosty glass filled with pure heaven.

The first sip was a revelation. The milkshake was mouthwateringly decadent and creamy, with just the right amount of sweetness. I could taste the richness of the ice cream and the luscious flavors that danced on my tongue.

But it wasn't just the milkshake that won me over. The friendly service provided by the Sonic team made my experience even more enjoyable. They were attentive, ensuring that my milkshake was served at the perfect temperature and offered additional toppings to customize my drink.

Sonic Drive-In offers a variety of menu choices, making it a destination for both milkshake aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. Whether you prefer classic chocolate or want to experiment with innovative flavors, they have something for everyone.

So, my dear readers, if you find yourself on the hunt for the perfect milkshake in New Braunfels, don't forget to swing by Sonic Drive-In. Trust me; it's an experience that will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Scoop Street

Highlights
Amazing staff
Delicious flavors
Vegan options available
Creative ice cream flavors

Walking into Scoop Street, I was greeted by an amazing staff, who were not only friendly but also knowledgeable about their wide range of milkshake options. They were eager to make suggestions based on my preferences, ensuring that I had the best milkshake experience possible.

Now, let me tell you about the flavors. Wow! Scoop Street offers a variety of delicious flavors that left my taste buds dancing in delight. From classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to more unique concoctions like caramel pretzel and strawberry cheesecake, they have something for everyone. Each milkshake was expertly crafted with just the right amount of sweetness, and the consistency was perfect - not too thick or too thin.

What sets Scoop Street apart is their commitment to catering to different dietary needs. They have vegan options available, so even those with dietary restrictions can indulge in a creamy and flavorful milkshake. I was impressed by the creativity and variety they offer in their ice cream flavors, both traditional and vegan.

Scoop Street truly takes the milkshake experience to the next level. The combination of their amazing staff, a wide range of delicious flavors, and the inclusion of vegan options makes them a top contender for the best milkshake in New Braunfels. Whether you're a milkshake aficionado or just someone looking to satisfy a sweet craving, Scoop Street is definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers

Highlights
Family favorite
Consistent quality food
Good seasoning on fries
Delicious concrete desserts
Friendly service at the window

From the moment I stepped into Freddy's, I knew it was going to be a family favorite. The atmosphere was lively, with families enjoying their meals and making lasting memories.

When it comes to milkshakes, Freddy's doesn't disappoint. Their consistently high-quality shakes are a dream come true for milkshake enthusiasts like myself. Smooth and creamy, these milkshakes are a true indulgence.

As I sipped on my shake, I couldn't help but notice the attention to detail in their menu. From the perfectly seasoned fries to the hearty burgers, Freddy's knows how to satisfy cravings. The good seasoning on their fries added an extra flair to my meal.

But let's not forget about their famed concrete desserts. These concoctions are a delightful blend of creamy frozen custard and a myriad of delectable mix-ins. I opted for the chocolate brownie concrete, and it was an explosion of flavors in every bite. Pure bliss!

I must also mention the outstanding friendly service I received at the window. The staff greeted me with smiles and genuine enthusiasm. It's those little touches that make the experience at Freddy's even more enjoyable.

In conclusion, Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers in New Braunfels is a milkshake lover's paradise. Their shakes are an irresistible treat, and their concrete desserts are a must-try. With consistent quality food and friendly service, Freddy's is an excellent choice for those in search of the best milkshake in New Braunfels.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX

Highlights
Homemade waffle cones
Interesting flavors
Retro ice cream shop atmosphere
Friendly and attentive service

First and foremost, let's talk about the highlights of this delightful ice cream shop. They take pride in their homemade waffle cones, which adds an extra crunch to every bite. The interesting flavors available are a true treat for your taste buds, ranging from classics like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations like lavender honey and salted caramel pretzel. It's a paradise for those looking to step out of their comfort zones.

Not only are the milkshakes at Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX delicious, the retro ice cream shop atmosphere takes you back in time. The vintage decor, complete with a jukebox playing your favorite tunes, creates a fun and nostalgic ambiance. It's the perfect spot to indulge in a well-deserved milkshake.

But a great milkshake experience isn't just about the flavors and ambiance; it's also about the service. And let me tell you, the friendly and attentive service at Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX is top-notch. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure you have an exceptional visit. They're happy to provide recommendations and accommodate any special requests you may have.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best milkshake in New Braunfels, look no further than Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX. With their homemade waffle cones, interesting flavors, retro atmosphere, and friendly service, they check all the boxes for a memorable milkshake experience. So why not treat yourself to a delicious milkshake and step back in time at Rheas Ice Cream- NBTX? You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

Marble Slab Creamery

Highlights
Coconut Ice cream
Make your own special
Friendly staff
Peaceful atmosphere

Marble Slab Creamery in New Braunfels is a milkshake lover's paradise. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the intoxicating aroma of fresh, homemade ice cream. The first thing that caught my eye was the vast array of flavors, but what really stood out were their coconut ice cream options.

I decided to create my own milkshake and was delighted by the vast selection of mix-ins available. From crushed Oreos to fresh berries, the possibilities were endless. As a self-proclaimed milkshake connoisseur, I appreciated being able to customize my indulgence to my exact taste.

Aside from the incredible selection, the staff at Marble Slab Creamery were both welcoming and knowledgeable. They were more than happy to assist in creating my dream milkshake and even offered suggestions for flavor combinations. Their friendly demeanor added to the overall peaceful atmosphere of the place.

As I savored every sip of my handcrafted masterpiece, I couldn't help but be impressed by the expert blending of flavors. The coconut ice cream was rich, creamy, and perfectly complemented the mix-ins I had chosen.

If you find yourself in New Braunfels and in need of a milkshake fix, Marble Slab Creamery is the place to go. With their wide selection of flavors, the option to create your own special, and their friendly staff, it's no wonder they top my list for the best milkshake in town.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Dairy Queen

Highlights
Amazing staff
Great variety
Friendly service
Clean dining
Delicious food

Upon stepping into Dairy Queen, I was greeted by an amazing staff who made me feel right at home. Their friendly smiles and warm welcome set the tone for a delightful milkshake experience.

The great variety of milkshakes on their menu left me in awe. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique concoctions like Oreo and strawberry cheesecake, Dairy Queen truly offers something for every taste bud. I appreciated the option to customize my milkshake with various toppings and mix-ins, ensuring a personalized treat.

Not only did Dairy Queen excel in milkshake selection, but their friendly service was exceptional. The staff was knowledgeable and eager to assist, making recommendations based on my preferences. I felt valued as a customer, and their attentive nature enhanced the overall experience.

The clean dining area impressed me as well. The tables were well-maintained, and the atmosphere was inviting. I appreciated the attention to detail in creating a pleasant environment to enjoy my milkshake.

Last but certainly not least, the milkshakes themselves were delicious. Each sip was a blissful explosion of flavors. The smooth consistency and rich taste were a testament to the quality ingredients used.

In conclusion, my visit to Dairy Queen in New Braunfels was a sweet and satisfying affair. From the amazing staff and great variety to the friendly service and clean dining, Dairy Queen knows how to create a remarkable milkshake experience. If you're looking for the best milkshake in town, look no further than Dairy Queen.

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Baskin-Robbins

Highlights
Creative custom cakes
Friendly staff
Fantastic ice cream
Favorite place in town

Walking into Baskin-Robbins in New Braunfels, I was instantly transported to a milkshake lover's paradise. With a colorful array of ice cream flavors and the enticing aroma of freshly baked waffle cones, I knew I was in for a treat.

What sets Baskin-Robbins apart from other milkshake destinations in New Braunfels is their commitment to creativity. The ability to customize your milkshake with any combination of their fantastic ice cream flavors is a game-changer. Whether you prefer classics like chocolate and vanilla or want to venture into more adventurous territory with flavors like pistachio or peanut butter and jelly, they've got you covered.

The friendly staff at Baskin-Robbins is the cherry on top of the milkshake experience. They are always ready to offer their suggestions and recommendations, ensuring that each customer finds their perfect milkshake match.

And let's not forget their fantastic ice cream. Every milkshake I tried was a creamy delight, blending perfectly with the mix-ins I chose. Whether it was Oreos, Reese's peanut butter cups, or fresh strawberries, each milkshake was a flavor explosion that left me longing for more.

It's no wonder that Baskin-Robbins is a favorite place in town for milkshake enthusiasts. With their creative custom cakes, friendly staff, and fantastic ice cream, they have truly earned their spot on the list of the best milkshake destinations in New Braunfels. So if you're in the mood for a milkshake that's worth every calorie, head on over to Baskin-Robbins and indulge in their irresistible creations.

You might also want to check out the best steak in San Antonio.

Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene

Highlights
Yummy and fresh flavors
Unique and specialized
Homemade taste
Goat cheese/raspberry
Amazing ice cream

From the moment I walked into the charming shop, I was greeted with the tantalizing aroma of freshly churned homemade ice cream. The atmosphere of Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a sweet indulgence.

What sets Rhea's apart from other establishments is their commitment to creating milkshakes with yummy and fresh flavors. Each shake is made to order, ensuring that every sip bursts with a burst of flavor. The menu boasts a range of unique and specialized options, but if you're feeling adventurous, try the Goat Cheese and Raspberry milkshake. It might sound like an unconventional combination, but trust me, the tangy goat cheese perfectly complements the sweetness of the raspberry. It's an unexpected delight that will leave your taste buds dancing.

The quality of the ice cream at Rhea's is unparalleled. The homemade taste is evident in every spoonful, and it's clear that the owners take great pride in their creations. The ice cream itself is creamy and smooth, with a richness that can only come from using the finest ingredients.

If you're searching for the best milkshake in New Braunfels, look no further than Rhea's Ice Cream - Gruene. Their commitment to creating amazing ice cream and their willingness to experiment with flavors truly sets them apart. Treat yourself to a milkshake experience like no other, and let Rhea's transport you to milkshake heaven.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast tacos in San Antonio.

Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels

Highlights
Lightest shaved ice
Fluffiest texture
Refreshing flavors
Fast and efficient service

Walking into Bahama Buck's, I was hit with an instant wave of excitement. The vibrant colors and lively atmosphere set the perfect stage for what turned out to be a delightful milkshake adventure.

Let's start with the star of the show: the milkshakes. Bahama Buck's is renowned for their lightest shaved ice and they've carried that expertise into their milkshakes. The texture had me floating on a cloud of satisfaction. Fluffy doesn't even begin to describe it. It was like sipping a heavenly milkshake cloud straight from the heavens.

And the flavors! Oh my, the flavors. Bahama Buck's offers an array of refreshing options to choose from, each one more tempting than the last. I found myself torn between the classic chocolate and their exotic Blue Coconut. The chocolate was velvety and rich, while the Blue Coconut transported me to a tropical paradise.

One thing that particularly stood out was the fast and efficient service. Despite the bustling crowd, the staff moved swiftly, ensuring that everyone got their milkshake fix in no time at all. I appreciated their dedication to providing a top-notch experience while keeping the milkshakes flowing.

In conclusion, Bahama Buck's - New Braunfels brings together the perfect combination of lightest shaved ice, fluffy texture, refreshing flavors, and fast and efficient service. When it comes to finding the best milkshake in New Braunfels, Bahama Buck's is a true contender. It's a place where milkshake dreams come true. Don't just take my word for it; savor the experience for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best tamales in San Antonio.

Muck & Fuss Craft Beer and Burgers

Let me indulge you with a brief yet delectable review of Muck & Fuss Craft Beer and Burgers, a popular spot in New Braunfels for burger enthusiasts and milkshake connoisseurs. Prepare your taste buds for a playful swirl of flavors that will surely leave you wanting more.

Tin Top Burger Shop

Unfortunately, Tin Top Burger Shop doesn't offer milkshakes on their menu. However, they have some mouthwatering burgers that deserve a shoutout in my article about the best milkshake in New Braunfels. So, if you're in the mood for a tasty burger, Tin Top Burger Shop is worth a visit!

The shack

Let me tell you, folks, The shack sure knows how to whip up a mean milkshake! The moment I took my first sip, I was transported to milkshake heaven. The creamy texture and rich flavors were out of this world. Trust me, this place is a must-try for all milkshake enthusiasts in New Braunfels!

Paleteria La Reina

Paleteria La Reina in New Braunfels is a hidden gem when it comes to milkshakes. Their creamy concoctions are out of this world. The flavors are exquisite, ranging from classic to exotic. It's a must-visit spot for milkshake aficionados in New Braunfels.

P. Terry's Burger Stand #20

After trying the milkshakes at P. Terry's Burger Stand #20 in New Braunfels, it's safe to say they're udderly delicious! The creamy texture and rich flavors make it a top contender for the title of best milkshake in town. Don't miss out on this shake-tastic experience!