San Antonio's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed 15 pizzerias in the Alamo City, I’ve tasted everything from the classic margherita to the bold pepperoni pie.

Each slice I sampled was a journey through the world of New York-style pizza, showcasing the delicious crust, tangy sauce, and perfectly melted cheese that defines this iconic dish.

In a city known for its Tex-Mex and BBQ, it’s exciting to see a growing scene for this beloved pizza style.

Join me as I explore the top contenders, dissecting what makes each one unique and worth a visit.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Highlights
Delicious pizza options
Friendly and fast service
Family-friendly ambiance
Large, satisfying calzones
Clean environment

Visiting Grimaldi's Pizzeria was like stepping into a New York establishment, right here in San Antonio. As I approached the restaurant, I was led by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza. The friendly and fast service was the cherry on top—within moments of being seated, I felt welcomed, as if I were a regular.

Now, onto the star of the show: the pizza. With a variety of delicious options on the menu, deciding on one was a delightful challenge. I finally settled on their classic margherita and I was not disappointed. The crust was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness, and each bite burst with flavor. Topped with fresh basil and mozzarella, it was a true testament to authentic New York style.

To round out the experience, I couldn’t resist trying one of their large, satisfying calzones, which were equally delightful and packed with cheesy goodness. The ambiance was remarkably family-friendly, making it an ideal spot for gatherings. Cleanliness only added to the overall appeal. If you’re hunting for pizza perfection in San Antonio, Grimaldi's is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

Poppys Pizza

Highlights
Perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio
Thin crust cooked to perfection
Fluffy, sweet cheesecake
Excellent wing options
Highly recommended by customers

When I set foot in Poppys Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. As I embraced the aroma wafting through the air, I couldn’t help but admire the charming décor, reminiscent of a pizza joint in the heart of Manhattan. It wasn’t long before I placed my order, eager to dive into the slices of New York that have garnered quite the local acclaim.

The moment I took my first bite, I was greeted with a perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio. The sauce was tangy yet rich, placing a delightful emphasis on the high-quality toppings. The thin crust was cooked to perfection, providing that iconic crunch while still managing to be fluffy enough to hold its shape. Each slice felt like a slice of heaven – quite literally!

To complement my pizza indulgence, I dove into their excellent wing options, which were crispy and flavorful. And no visit would be complete without trying their fluffy, sweet cheesecake for dessert—it's a must!

With an unwavering commitment to quality and a welcoming atmosphere, Poppys Pizza truly stands out in San Antonio's pizza scene. I can confidently say this gem is worthy of a visit for any pizza lover!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Barbaro

Highlights
Cozy neighborhood area
Great alternative music
Top quality Happy Hour drinks
Friendly staff
Top 3 pizza in SA

Walking into Barbaro, I immediately felt the warm and cozy vibes of the neighborhood spot. The ambiance was inviting, with an eclectic mix of alternative music playing in the background, creating a unique and laid-back atmosphere.

But let's get to the main attraction – the pizza. Barbaro did not disappoint. Their New York style pizza is undoubtedly one of the best in San Antonio. The thin and crispy crust had just the right amount of chewiness, and the sauce was bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful combination of melted cheese, savory toppings, and that perfect balance of tang and sweetness from the sauce.

One thing that stood out to me was their commitment to quality. The ingredients used were clearly fresh and top-notch. Whether it was the homemade mozzarella or the locally sourced toppings, Barbaro truly goes above and beyond to create an exceptional pizza experience.

Aside from their outstanding pizza, Barbaro also boasts a fantastic Happy Hour. Their selection of drinks is extensive, and each sip showcases the craftsmanship that goes into creating them. From classic cocktails to innovative concoctions, they have something to suit every taste. And with their friendly and knowledgeable staff, you'll always feel well taken care of.

After my visit, I can confidently say that Barbaro deserves its spot among the top three pizza places in San Antonio. The combination of mouthwatering pizza, cozy atmosphere, and top-quality drinks make for an unforgettable dining experience. So, if you're in search of the best New York style pizza in San Antonio, make sure to add Barbaro to your list – you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria

Highlights
Really good pizza
Simple and accurate online ordering
Cheerful and friendly staff
Convenient parking location next to an HEB
"The Works" pizza is the real deal

Walking into Yaghi's, I immediately noticed the enticing aroma of really good pizza. The place had a cozy and inviting atmosphere, with cheerful staff ready to take my order.

One thing I appreciated about Yaghi's was their simple and accurate online ordering system. I could easily customize my pizza with all my favorite toppings, and the website made it easy to place my order for pickup.

When I arrived to pick up my pizza, I was greeted with a smile by the friendly staff. They handed me my piping hot box and informed me about their convenient parking location next to an HEB. This was a nice bonus, as it made it easy for me to grab some drinks and snacks to go along with my pizza.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. Oh my, it was the real deal! I ordered "The Works" pizza, and it truly lived up to its name. The crust was thin and crispy, just as it should be for a true New York style pizza. The toppings were generous and perfectly balanced, showcasing the flavors of tangy marinara, gooey cheese, and a variety of savory meats and vegetables. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors.

In conclusion, Yaghi's New York Pizzeria is a must-visit for any pizza lover in San Antonio. With their really good pizza, simple online ordering, cheerful staff, and convenient parking location, they ticked all the boxes for an exceptional pizza experience. Don't miss out on their "The Works" pizza – it's the real deal!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Florio's Pizza Inc,

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Thin and crispy
Affordable prices
Great service
Authentic atmosphere

From the moment I walked into Florio's Pizza Inc, I knew I was in for a treat. The delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air and my taste buds began to tingle with excitement.

I eagerly ordered a classic New York style pizza and waited in anticipation. The friendly staff provided excellent service and made me feel right at home. As I sat in the cozy and authentic atmosphere, I couldn't help but admire the charming decor that transported me straight to the streets of New York City.

When my pizza arrived, I couldn't help but marvel at its beauty. The thin and crispy crust was adorned with generous amounts of gooey cheese and a rich tomato sauce that had just the right balance of sweetness and tanginess. Each bite was a delightful combination of flavors that danced on my tongue.

What impressed me most was not just the taste, but also the affordable prices. Florio's Pizza Inc offers an incredible value for such high-quality pizza. I felt like I was getting a taste of New York City without breaking the bank.

Overall, Florio's Pizza Inc had all the elements that make for a great New York style pizza experience. The combination of delicious pizza, thin and crispy crust, affordable prices, and great service truly set this place apart. Whether you're a true New Yorker or just longing for a taste of the Big Apple, Florio's Pizza Inc is a must-try in San Antonio.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

Capos Pizzeria

Highlights
Clean
Delicious
Welcoming
Great price
Tasty toppings

Walking into Capos Pizzeria, I was immediately impressed by the clean and inviting atmosphere. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. Oh boy, it was delicious. The thin crust had the perfect balance of crunchiness and chewiness, just like an authentic New York slice. The generous portions of cheese were perfectly melted, creating a molten blanket of cheesy goodness.

What truly made this pizza stand out were the tasty toppings. The options were plentiful, ranging from classic pepperoni to unique combinations like prosciutto and arugula. Each bite was a flavorful explosion, showcasing the quality ingredients used by Capos Pizzeria.

Not only did the pizza taste amazing, but it was also great value for the price. I left feeling satisfied and my wallet feeling happy.

Overall, Capos Pizzeria exceeded my expectations. The combination of their welcoming atmosphere, clean space, delicious pizza, and reasonable prices make it a top contender for the best New York style pizza in San Antonio. If you're in the mood for a slice of pizza heaven, look no further than Capos Pizzeria.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Alamo Ranch

Highlights
Go-to for pizza
Kid approved
Super friendly staff
Delicious and worth the price

Upon entering the pizzeria, I immediately knew I was in for a treat. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with pizza lovers of all ages savoring their slices. It's no wonder this place is a go-to for pizza in San Antonio!

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the wide variety of options, from classic cheese and pepperoni to unique specialty pies. I decided to go with a traditional pepperoni, and boy, was I impressed! The crust was thin and crispy, just the way a true New York style pizza should be. The delicious flavors of the sauce and cheese blended perfectly with the savory slices of pepperoni.

What truly stood out to me at 46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Alamo Ranch was the super friendly staff. They were incredibly knowledgeable about their pizzas and took the time to answer all of my questions. Their passion for creating mouthwatering pies was evident in every interaction.

Kid-approved, this pizzeria is perfect for families as well. There's a dedicated area for little ones to play while their parents enjoy their meal. This thoughtful touch made the experience even more enjoyable.

Some might argue that the price of a New York style pizza is a little higher, but let me tell you, it's worth every penny at 46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Alamo Ranch. The quality of the ingredients and the dedication to crafting an authentic slice of New York is truly exceptional.

In conclusion, if you're in San Antonio and craving an authentic New York style pizza, don't hesitate to visit 46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Alamo Ranch. It's the perfect place to indulge in a slice of cheesy perfection.

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Ray's Pizza and Gelato

HIGHLIGHTS
Great tangy sauce
Delicious Alfredo
Family pizza night
Excellent customer service
Variety of menu options

As I walked into Ray's Pizza and Gelato, I couldn't help but notice the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. The friendly staff greeted me with a warm smile, immediately making me feel welcome.

I decided to start with their classic cheese pizza to truly test the authenticity of their New York style. The first bite was heavenly. The thin, crispy crust had the perfect balance of chewiness, providing a satisfying crunch with each bite. The tangy tomato sauce was incredible, adding a burst of flavor that complemented the gooey, melted cheese.

Feeling a bit more adventurous, I also tried their Alfredo pizza. The combination of the creamy Alfredo sauce, tender chicken, and fragrant herbs had my taste buds dancing with delight. It was a decadent twist on a classic favorite.

Ray's Pizza and Gelato is the ideal spot for a family pizza night. The cozy atmosphere and friendly ambiance create the perfect backdrop for enjoying a delicious meal together. The generous portion sizes ensure that everyone leaves fully satisfied.

What truly sets Ray's Pizza and Gelato apart is their commitment to excellent customer service. The attentive staff went above and beyond to ensure my dining experience was exceptional. Their knowledge of the menu and eagerness to accommodate my preferences left a lasting impression.

Whether you're craving a slice of classic New York style pizza or seeking a unique flavor combination, Ray's Pizza and Gelato has something for everyone. From their great tangy sauce to their delicious Alfredo, they offer a variety of menu options that will satisfy even the pickiest of pizza enthusiasts. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in San Antonio!

You might also want to check out the best steak in San Antonio.

46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Bulverde Road

Highlights
Fresh and hot
Delicious pizza and wings
Quality ingredients
Amazing flavors

Let me start by saying that this place has got it going on! From the moment I walked in, I could smell the aroma of freshly-baked pizza. My taste buds were already salivating.

The pizza they served was the epitome of what a New York style pizza should be. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, just like it should. Each bite was filled with the delightful combination of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The cheese was perfectly melted and gooey, which added to the overall perfection of the pizza.

Speaking of toppings, they had a wide variety to choose from. Whether you are a fan of classic toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms, or prefer something a little more adventurous like buffalo chicken or artichoke hearts, they've got you covered. The ingredients were of top-notch quality, which made for an exceptional pizza-eating experience.

Now, let's talk about the wings. Oh boy! They were finger-licking good. The wings were juicy, flavorful, and had that perfect amount of kick. The buffalo sauce was tangy and mildly spicy, just the way I like it.

Overall, 46th St. New York Style Pizzeria/Bulverde Road had everything I was looking for in a New York style pizza joint. The pizza was delicious, the wings were amazing, and the flavor combinations were out of this world. If you're ever in San Antonio, make sure to pay a visit to this establishment. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast tacos in San Antonio.

Maar's Pizza & More

Highlights
Awesome food
Great service
Large pizzas at a great price
Unique and awesome decor
Funko pops for sale

Upon stepping into Maar's Pizza & More, I was immediately drawn in by its unique and awesome decor. The whimsical combination of vintage arcade games, movie posters, and Funko pops for sale created a truly one-of-a-kind atmosphere.

As I sat down at my table, I was promptly greeted by the friendly staff, who provided great service throughout my visit. They were helpful in answering any questions I had and made me feel right at home.

Now let's talk about the most important aspect - the pizza! And boy, did Maar's deliver! I ordered their new york style pizza and it was simply awesome. The crust was thin, yet delightfully chewy, just like they do it in the Big Apple. The sauce had the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness, while the cheese was gooey and absolutely divine.

But what truly sets Maar's apart is the size of their pizzas and their great price. These pies are as big as the city skyline, allowing you to indulge in true New York style goodness without breaking the bank. Each slice was a generous mouthful of flavors coming together in perfect harmony.

Overall, Maar's Pizza & More met and exceeded my expectations. From the awesome food and great service to the playful decor and large pizzas at a great price, it is clear to me that Maar's is a top contender for the title of the best new york style pizza in San Antonio.

You might also want to check out the best tamales in San Antonio.

Trilogy Pizza Bistro

Oh boy, let me tell you, Trilogy Pizza Bistro is a game-changer when it comes to New York style pizza in San Antonio. From the crispy yet chewy crust to the flavorful sauce and generous toppings, this place knows how to make a pizza that would even impress the pizza gods themselves. The combination of quality ingredients and skilled craftsmanship truly make every bite a taste of pizza perfection. Trilogy Pizza Bistro has definitely earned a spot on the list of the best New York style pizzas in San Antonio.

Big Lou's Pizza

Big Lou's Pizza in San Antonio is a must-visit for any pizza lover. Their New York style slices are big, bold, and beautiful. With generous toppings and a thin, crispy crust, every bite is a slice of heaven. Don't miss their signature 42-inch pizza that's perfect for sharing with friends. Big Lou's is truly a pizza paradise in the heart of San Antonio.

Chicago's Pizza

Chicago's Pizza in San Antonio is a hidden gem that will transport you straight to the bustling streets of New York City. The thin and crispy crust is crafted with precision, providing the perfect base for a harmonious blend of tangy sauce and gooey cheese. The toppings are piled on in generous amounts, offering a burst of flavor in every bite. Their dedication to using authentic ingredients shines through, creating a pizza that is both nostalgic and irresistible. If you're searching for a taste of the Big Apple in the heart of San Antonio, Chicago's Pizza is a must-try.

Pizzeria Vesuvio

Pizzeria Vesuvio in San Antonio, a hidden gem for New York style pizza lovers, did not disappoint. The thin and crispy crust had just the right amount of chewiness, while the tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese were a match made in pizza heaven. Vesuvio's attention to details with quality ingredients and generous toppings made each bite a delightful explosion of flavors. The staff's friendly demeanor and prompt service added to the overall pleasant experience. It's safe to say that Pizzeria Vesuvio has earned its spot on the list of the best New York style pizzas in San Antonio.

Sorrento Pizza & Restaurant

Sorrento Pizza & Restaurant in San Antonio is a hidden gem for pizza lovers seeking that authentic New York flavor. With a chewy crust, savory sauce, and gooey cheese, every bite transports you to the bustling streets of the Big Apple. If you're on a quest for the best, Sorrento is a must-try.