New Braunfels' Best Pie [Updated 2024]

I've embarked on a delightful mission, sampling and savoring pies from every corner of this charming Texan town. With 15 delectable contenders under my belt, I can confidently say that I have found the crème de la crème.

So, buckle up and get ready for a mouthwatering adventure! From flaky crusts to tantalizing fillings, I'll be sharing my lighthearted and scrumptious discoveries.

So, whether you're craving a classic apple pie or an innovative twist, join me as we uncover the true pie gems of New Braunfels.

New Braunfels Coffee

Highlights
Excellent breakfast croissant
Delicious pastries
Relaxing atmosphere
Free wifi available
Friendly service

Let me start by saying, if you're looking for a place that serves up a mean slice of pie, you might be surprised to find it at New Braunfels Coffee. While they may not specialize in pie, their selection is definitely worth a try.

The first thing that caught my attention at New Braunfels Coffee was their excellent breakfast croissant. I couldn't resist sinking my teeth into the flaky layers of buttery goodness. It was a delightful start to my pie-tasting journey.

Moving on to their pastries, I must admit I was impressed. From fruit-filled turnovers to perfectly baked muffins, everything was delicious. But it was their pie selection that really stole the show. The flaky crusts, the mouthwatering fillings, it was hard to choose just one.

What I loved most about New Braunfels Coffee was the relaxing atmosphere. It's the kind of place where you can sit back, enjoy a cup of coffee, and savor a slice of pie. With free wifi available, it's also a great spot to get some work done or catch up on emails.

But the true cherry on top was the friendly service. The staff at New Braunfels Coffee made me feel welcome from the moment I walked in. Their warm smiles and helpful recommendations only enhanced the overall experience.

While New Braunfels Coffee may not be solely dedicated to pie, it is definitely a hidden gem in the search for the best pie in New Braunfels. So, if you're in the mood for a slice of pie that's accompanied by a welcoming ambiance and outstanding service, I highly recommend giving New Braunfels Coffee a try.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in San Antonio.

Above Ground Pizza

Highlights
Great food and atmosphere
Love put into every dish
Friendly and welcoming service
Excellent garlic rings
Highly recommended

When I walked into Above Ground Pizza, I instantly felt a warmth in the air. The friendly and welcoming staff greeted me with genuine smiles. The pizza joint had a relaxed ambiance, with funky decor that added to its charm.

As a pie enthusiast, I couldn't help but get excited about the variety of options on the menu. I decided to start with their highly recommended dishes, starting with their famous garlic rings. Oh, the aroma that wafted from those golden, excellent garlic rings! Each bite was crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, with just the right amount of garlicky goodness.

For the main event, I ordered their signature pizza, and boy, was I in for a treat! The dough was perfectly soft and fluffy on the inside, with a delightful crisp on the outside. The toppings were generously piled on, and the combination of flavors danced on my taste buds. It was clear that love was put into every dish that came out of the kitchen.

Above Ground Pizza has truly mastered the art of pizza-making. The attention to detail and the passion behind each creation shines through in every bite. The great food and atmosphere make it a fantastic spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family.

If you're in New Braunfels and looking for the best pie in town, I highly recommend paying a visit to Above Ground Pizza. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in San Antonio.

emerald Whisk

Highlights
Best baked products
Delicious cakes and cookies
Creative and flavorful offerings

Walking into emerald Whisk, I was immediately greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked goodies. Being a pie aficionado, I was eager to taste their offerings and see if they lived up to their reputation. And boy, did they ever!

Let me start by saying that emerald Whisk truly excels in their baked products. From the moment I took my first bite of their pies, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. Each slice was a symphony of flavors, perfectly balanced and expertly baked to golden perfection. The crust was flaky, buttery, and provided the perfect vessel to hold the delectable fillings.

Not only did emerald Whisk offer a wide variety of pies, but their other baked goods were equally impressive. Their cakes were moist and flavorful, and their cookies were a delight to indulge in. It was as if they had unlocked the secret to creating the most divine sweets imaginable.

What sets emerald Whisk apart from the rest is their creativity. They constantly innovate and create new and exciting flavors that keep their customers on their toes. From classic apple pie with a twist to unique combinations like chocolate peanut butter banana cream, they always have something new and tantalizing to offer.

Whether you're a pie lover, a cake connoisseur, or simply on the hunt for the best baked products in New Braunfels, emerald Whisk is a must-visit. Their commitment to quality, flavor, and creativity ensures that every bite is pure bliss. So, grab a fork, indulge in a slice of pie, and let emerald Whisk take your taste buds on a tantalizing adventure.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in New Braunfels.

Tipsy Cow Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique flavors
High-quality ingredients
Boozy options
Creamy and smooth texture
Fun twist on ice cream

Let me start by saying that Tipsy Cow Ice Cream is not your ordinary ice cream shop. It's a place where playfulness meets professionalism, and the result is a delightful twist on traditional frozen treats.

One of the highlights at Tipsy Cow is their unique flavors. Forget about your typical chocolate and vanilla. Here, you'll find flavors like Bourbon Pecan Pie, Margarita Lime, and even Whiskey Caramel Swirl. Each scoop is bursting with creativity and will leave both your taste buds and imagination satisfied.

But it's not just the flavors that set Tipsy Cow apart. They use high-quality ingredients to ensure that every bite is pure bliss. From locally sourced fruits to premium cream and chocolate, you can taste the difference in every spoonful.

Now, let's talk about the boozy options. If you're feeling a bit adventurous, Tipsy Cow has got you covered. The alcohol-infused ice creams add an extra kick to your experience. Picture yourself enjoying a slice of heavenly pie in the form of a frozen treat. It's a whimsical twist that elevates the ice cream game.

Aside from the innovative flavors and boozy options, Tipsy Cow manages to uphold the creamy and smooth texture we all look for in ice cream. Each scoop is velvety and satisfying, making you savor every single bite.

In conclusion, Tipsy Cow Ice Cream offers a fun twist on ice cream while maintaining a level of professionalism that truly sets them apart. Their unique flavors, high-quality ingredients, and boozy options make for a memorable experience. Whether you're on the hunt for the best pie in New Braunfels or simply craving a delightful frozen treat, Tipsy Cow won't disappoint.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Antonio.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Highlights
Friendly staff
Diabetic-friendly options
Light and fluffy cakes
Best cake ever
Wide variety of flavors

As soon as I walked into Nothing Bundt Cakes, I was greeted by the warm smiles of the friendly staff. They were eager to assist and recommended their diabetic-friendly options for those with dietary restrictions. This got me excited to try their unique take on pies.

I couldn't help but notice the irresistible aroma wafting through the bakery. Each cake was meticulously decorated, making it almost too pretty to eat. But who could resist trying the best cake ever, right?

I opted for their classic vanilla flavor, and boy, was I blown away! The first bite revealed a moist and light cake that practically melted in my mouth. The frosting was divine, not too overpowering, and complemented the cake perfectly. It was like tasting a little piece of heaven.

What impressed me the most was the wide variety of flavors available. From chocolate to red velvet, lemon to cinnamon swirl, Nothing Bundt Cakes had something to satisfy every craving. Whether you prefer a traditional flavor or want to explore something new, they've got you covered.

Overall, Nothing Bundt Cakes exceeded my expectations. Their cakes are a true delight for the taste buds, and the experience is a treat for the eyes as well. Don't just take my word for it, head over to Nothing Bundt Cakes and indulge in a slice of pure bliss. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

The Honey Baked Ham Company

Highlights
Best ham and cheese sandwich!
Delicious trio of turkey sliders
Well oiled machine of employees
Friendly and welcoming atmosphere
Accommodating expired gift cards

As I stepped into The Honey Baked Ham Company, I was immediately greeted by a friendly and welcoming atmosphere that set the tone for my visit. The scent of deliciously baked ham filled the air, but I had to remind myself to stay focused on my mission: finding the best pie in New Braunfels.

It didn't take long for me to discover that this place wasn't just about the ham. I was pleasantly surprised by their selection of pies on display. While their main attraction may be the succulent hams, their pies were equally delightful. Each slice was a masterpiece, perfectly cradled in a flaky crust that almost begged to be devoured.

The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly their best ham and cheese sandwich. Layers of juicy ham were sandwiched between two slices of bread, topped with melted cheese that oozed with every bite. It was the kind of sandwich that brought back childhood memories and made me crave more.

But let's not forget the trio of turkey sliders. Each slider was a miniature masterpiece, bursting with flavor. The combination of tender turkey, tangy cranberry sauce, and savory stuffing was a delightful taste explosion in every bite.

One thing that stood out to me about The Honey Baked Ham Company was their well-oiled machine of employees. The staff worked seamlessly together, ensuring every customer was attended to with care and efficiency. It was evident that they took pride in their craft and were passionate about what they do.

In a surprising twist, The Honey Baked Ham Company showed their commitment to customer satisfaction by accommodating expired gift cards. It's rare to find such kindness and understanding in today's world, and it left a lasting impression on me.

While The Honey Baked Ham Company may not be solely focused on pie, they definitely know how to deliver delicious flavors in every bite. Their pies were a delightful addition to their already impressive menu. If you're looking for a place that offers a generous selection of mouthwatering pies alongside their beloved hams, this is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Naegelin's German Bakery

Highlights
European pastries
Wide selection of pastries
Delicious cherry strudel
Best bakery in town

Let me start by saying, if you're looking for a slice of heaven in New Braunfels, look no further than Naegelin's German Bakery. This charming bakery is a little taste of Europe in the heart of Texas, and their selection of pastries is nothing short of extraordinary.

Walking into Naegelin's, you're immediately greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked goods. The display case is a sight to behold, showcasing an exquisite assortment of delicate treats that will make your mouth water. From flaky croissants to decadent danishes, this bakery has something for everyone.

Now, let's talk about the pie. The cherry strudel at Naegelin's is an absolute delight. With its buttery, melt-in-your-mouth pastry and sweet, tangy cherries, every bite is a little taste of perfection. The filling is bursting with flavor, and the crust strikes the perfect balance between flaky and tender. It's the kind of pie that makes you close your eyes and savor the moment.

But the cherry strudel is just the tip of the iceberg at Naegelin's. Their commitment to quality and craftsmanship is evident in every pastry they create. Whether you prefer apple, peach, or pecan, you can trust that each pie will be made with the utmost care and attention to detail.

In my humble opinion, Naegelin's German Bakery is the best bakery in town. Their European pastries are absolutely divine, and the cherry strudel alone is worth the visit. So, if you find yourself in New Braunfels craving a slice of pie perfection, make your way to Naegelin's. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

2tarts Bakery

Highlights
Fun and cute coffee shop
Amazing wedding cake and cupcakes
Delightful and personable staff
Talented at designing and drawing cakes
Delicious buttercream frosting

As I stepped into 2tarts Bakery, I was immediately charmed by the fun and cute coffee shop atmosphere. The colorful decor and delicious aromas wafting through the air set the stage for what turned out to be a delightful pie experience.

But before I dive into the pie, I have to mention the amazing wedding cakes and cupcakes that are also offered at this bakery. The bakers at 2tarts are truly talented artists, as they excel not only in baking but also in designing and drawing beautiful cakes. If you have a special occasion coming up, this bakery should definitely be on your list.

Now, let's talk about the pies. The first thing that caught my attention was the delightful and personable staff. They were not only knowledgeable about their pies, but they genuinely seemed excited to share their passion for baking with their customers.

I sampled a few different pies, and every single one was a winner. The crusts were flaky and buttery, while the fillings were rich and bursting with flavor. But what really took the cake, or should I say the pie, was the delicious buttercream frosting that adorned some of their creations. It was the perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess, and it elevated the pies to a whole new level.

Overall, my experience at 2tarts Bakery left me craving more. Their baked goods are not just tasty, but they are made with love and care. If you find yourself in New Braunfels, make sure to stop by and treat yourself to a slice of pie - you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Sweet Bites by Lizzie

Highlights
Delicious cakes
Professional service
Perfect pies in a jar
Helpful planning process

From the moment I stepped into Sweet Bites by Lizzie, I knew I was in for a treat. The delicious aroma of freshly baked pies filled the air, instantly making my mouth water. The display case was a feast for the eyes, filled with an array of colorful and enticing cakes. The friendly staff greeted me with a warm smile, providing professional and attentive service throughout my visit.

What sets Sweet Bites by Lizzie apart from other pie shops in New Braunfels is their unique twist on traditional pies - pies in a jar. These adorable little jars of heaven are the perfect size for indulging in a sweet treat without feeling guilty. The pies are beautifully layered, with a deliciously flaky crust and a generous filling bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful explosion of sweetness that left me craving for more.

But it wasn't just the pies in a jar that impressed me. What sets Sweet Bites by Lizzie apart is their helpful planning process. Whether you're ordering a pie for a special occasion or simply treating yourself, their friendly staff will guide you through the process, ensuring that you get exactly what you're looking for.

In my quest for the best pie in New Braunfels, Sweet Bites by Lizzie has definitely left a lasting impression. The combination of their delicious cakes, professional service, perfect pies in a jar, and helpful planning process makes them a true gem in the pie scene. If you're looking for a dessert that will satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more, Sweet Bites by Lizzie is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

New City Bakery

Highlights
Well-stocked
Sweet desserts
Reasonable prices
Helpful and polite staff
Amazing donuts

Upon walking into New City Bakery, I was immediately drawn to the well-stocked display counter that showcased a wide variety of mouthwatering pies and sweet desserts. The options seemed endless, leaving me undecided on which pie to try first.

The prices at New City Bakery were reasonable, making it an attractive option for those looking to indulge in a delicious slice of pie without breaking the bank. As I waited in line, the friendly and polite staff approached me with a warm smile, ready to assist in any way they could.

After much contemplation, I finally settled on a slice of their infamous apple pie. The crust was perfectly flaky, providing a delightful crunch with each bite. The filling was bursting with the sweetness of freshly picked apples, complemented by the perfect balance of cinnamon and spices. It was a truly heavenly experience for my taste buds.

Aside from their exceptional pies, I was pleasantly surprised to find that New City Bakery also offered amazing donuts. Their pillowy soft texture, paired with an array of delectable glazes and fillings, made it hard to resist indulging in more than just one.

Overall, New City Bakery has undoubtedly earned a spot on the list of the best pie places in New Braunfels. Their well-stocked selection, reasonable prices, and helpful staff make it a go-to destination for any pie lover. Make sure to stop by and treat yourself to a slice of their pie perfection!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Gainz Bakery Cafe & Prepared Meals

Oh, the joy that awaited me at Gainz Bakery Cafe & Prepared Meals in New Braunfels! The moment I sunk my fork into their delectable pie, I knew I had struck gold - or rather, pie heaven. Each heavenly slice was a perfect balance of flaky crust and mouthwatering filling. This place is a must-visit for any pie lover in the area!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in San Antonio.

New Braunfels Bakery & Cakes

New Braunfels Bakery & Cakes is a delightful pastry haven where pie dreams come true! The flaky crusts and tantalizing fillings are a testament to the bakers' artistry and flavorful expertise. From classic apple to unique creations, this place has a pie for every palate. A must-visit for any pie aficionado in New Braunfels!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in San Antonio.

H-E-B Bakery

At H-E-B Bakery in New Braunfels, I embarked on a pie-tasting adventure. The bakers' creativity and attention to detail shone through their delicious creations. From classic apple to decadent chocolate cream, each pie was a flaky masterpiece. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their scrumptious pies!

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Pat's Place

Pat's Place in New Braunfels is a hidden gem serving up mouth-watering pies that are simply irresistible. From the flaky crusts to the delectable fillings, each bite is a slice of heaven. Don't miss out on their signature pecan pie - it's a game-changer. Trust me, you won't leave disappointed!

Paislee’s bakery

With their wide range of flavors and flaky crusts, Paislee's bakery in New Braunfels truly impressed me in my quest for the best pie in town. Their pies are heavenly and their attention to detail is impeccable. I highly recommend giving Paislee's bakery a try!