New Braunfels' Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

After diving into the delightful world of pizza in New Braunfels, I can confidently say that this charming town has some hidden gems that could rival the best pizzerias out there. I’ve rolled up my sleeves and taste-tested 15 top spots, each with its own unique twist on that cheesy, saucy goodness we all crave.

With a passion for food that’s taken me from coast to coast, I’ve honed my palate to spot the real deal—and trust me, there are some seriously mouthwatering options here. Whether you’re a thin-crust fanatic or a deep-dish devotee, I’ve got the scoop on the must-try slices that will have you coming back for more. Let's dig in!

Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels

Highlights
Incredible homemade ranch
Friendly and welcoming service
Delicious spicy pepperoni
Variety of specialty pizzas
Cozy take-out atmosphere

When I stepped into Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels, I was instantly greeted by a cozy atmosphere that hinted at the culinary delights to come. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, setting the stage for a remarkable pizza adventure.

I decided to indulge in their spicy pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you – it was a fantastic choice! Each slice boasted a perfect balance of heat and zest, with the pepperoni adding just the right amount of kick. But what truly took the experience to another level was their incredible homemade ranch. I found myself dipping each bite, enhancing the flavors and making my taste buds dance with joy.

Mattenga's also offers a delightful variety of specialty pizzas, ideal for those who crave something a little different. The combination of cozy take-out vibes and delectable pies makes this spot a must-try in New Braunfels. Each visit feels like a celebration of flavors, so if you're in search of good pizza and joyous atmosphere, Mattenga's is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best parks in San Antonio.

Bootleggers Pizza Parlor

Highlights
Family-friendly atmosphere
Great pizza and ravioli
Central downtown location
Excellent service from staff
Delicious dessert options

When I stepped into Bootleggers Pizza Parlor, I was immediately greeted by a lively, family-friendly atmosphere that set the tone for a delightful evening. Nestled in the heart of downtown, this charming pizzeria is not just a place to grab a slice, but a community hub that invites you to kick back and enjoy good food.

The menu is a treasure trove of options, but I’d be remiss not to highlight their mouth-watering pizza and savory ravioli. Each bite of my pizza was a harmonious blend of fresh toppings and perfectly baked crust—a true testament to their craftsmanship. The staff at Bootleggers deserve special mention too; their service was not only prompt but infused with that warm, inviting charm that makes the dining experience truly enjoyable. After polishing off my slice, I couldn’t resist trying a dessert. And let me tell you, the sweet treats were the icing on the cake—a delightful end to a delicious meal.

If you’re in New Braunfels and craving pizza, make sure to pop into Bootleggers. It’s a slice above the rest! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best mall in San Antonio.

Above Ground Pizza

Highlights
Decent pizza flavor
Quality of ingredients lacking
Unwelcoming customer service
High prices for toppings
Could improve ambiance

Above Ground Pizza boasts a catchy name that suggests an elevated pizza experience, but my visit left me feeling a bit more grounded than I had hoped. The decent flavor of the pizza was a pleasant surprise, with its crispy crust that managed to hold together under the weight of toppings. However, it became apparent that the quality of ingredients just didn't quite hit the mark.

As I indulged in my slice, the toppings felt somewhat lackluster, a far cry from what I expected for the price I was paying. Topping costs ran high, and I found myself wishing for a pinch more zest to justify the expense. To add to this, the ambiance left much to be desired—nothing says "welcome" like a sterile, uninspired space.

Despite a good pizza flavor, my interaction with the staff was unwelcoming, missing that essential charm that brings customers back for more. In the vivacious world of New Braunfels pizza, Above Ground Pizza has some work to do if it hopes to rise above its competition. There's potential here, but it might take a bit of spice and heart to get there.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in San Antonio.

Mattenga's Pizzeria in New Braunfels Marketplace

Highlights
Perfect thin crust pizza
Delicious Supreme and Margherita
Wonderful atmosphere
Excellent customer service
Must-try Honey Bexar Pizza

As I stepped into Mattenga's Pizzeria in New Braunfels Marketplace, the delightful aromas of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese immediately captured my attention. The atmosphere was vibrant yet cozy, making it a perfect spot for a casual catch-up with friends or a family outing.

I decided to dive into their Supreme and Margherita pizzas, both of which showcased their perfect thin crust; crispy yet tender with just the right amount of chew. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, from the savory toppings of the Supreme—full of vibrant vegetables and meaty goodness—to the simple elegance of the Margherita, highlighting fresh basil and mozzarella.

What truly sets Mattenga's apart, however, is their Honey Bexar Pizza, an inventive treat that balances sweet and savory in a way that’s simply unforgettable. Not to mention, the staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that my experience was nothing short of fabulous.

In the world of pizza, Mattenga's has claimed a special place in my heart and my taste buds. It's a must-visit for anyone in search of the best pizza in New Braunfels!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in San Antonio.

New York Pizza Pub

Highlights
Delicious New York-style pizza
Friendly and helpful staff
Great dining atmosphere
Exceptional crust flavor
Inconsistent quality noted

New York Pizza Pub is truly a slice of heaven in New Braunfels! As soon as I stepped inside, I was welcomed by a warm and inviting atmosphere that immediately set the stage for a delightful pizza experience. The friendly and helpful staff made me feel right at home, offering recommendations that only heightened my anticipation.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself! True to its name, the New York-style pizza here boasts a remarkable flavor that transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York City. The exceptional crust is a masterclass in pizza-making—crispy on the outside yet perfectly chewy on the inside, allowing the toppings to shine without overshadowing their deliciousness.

However, I did notice a hint of inconsistency in the quality during my visit. While the overall experience is great, I've encountered varying levels of toppings and sauce richness in different slices.

Nonetheless, if you're in the mood for a hearty and satisfying meal, New York Pizza Pub is definitely worth a visit. Just remember, we’re here for the pizza, and this place might just leave you craving more! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best enchiladas in San Antonio.

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits

Highlights
Great flavor combinations
Friendly and accommodating staff
Pleasant dining ambience
Outstanding pasta options
Best pizza in New Braunfels

Review of Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits

When I think of the best pizza in New Braunfels, Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits instantly comes to mind. The moment you step in, the inviting ambience wraps around you like a warm hug. The staff is not just friendly but truly accommodating, ready to make recommendations that elevate your dining experience.

I opted for one of their signature pizzas, and let me tell you, the flavor combinations are nothing short of spectacular. The crust, kissed by the wood-fired oven, had that perfect balance of crispness and chewiness, serving as a delicious canvas for their fresh toppings. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors that made me smile.

And let’s not forget about the pasta options! While pizza is often the star of the show, Inferno's doesn’t overlook its pasta. The dishes are equally commendable, adding depth to a menu that already shines.

In a town filled with pizza joints, Inferno’s truly stands out. If you find yourself in New Braunfels craving authentic flavor, this place is an absolute must-visit! You won't just leave satisfied; you'll be dreaming of your next visit. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best furniture stores in San Antonio.

Calahan's Pub and Pizza

Highlights
Fresh, delicious pizza
Perfect texture crust
Highly recommended by locals
Excellent service experience
Must-try pepperoni & jalapenos

Calahan's Pub and Pizza is a local gem that truly deserves its spot among the best pizza joints in New Braunfels. As soon as I stepped inside, the welcoming atmosphere set the perfect tone for a delicious meal. The fresh, delicious pizza here is not just a claim; it’s a delightful reality! I opted for the pepperoni and jalapenos, a combination that dances on your palate with every bite.

What struck me most was the perfect texture crust—crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy within. It’s a delicate balance that Calahan’s has mastered, making it the perfect base for their high-quality toppings. I couldn't help but notice how highly recommended the place is among locals, and now I understand why.

The service was impeccable, with staff eager to ensure that my experience was top-notch. They made me feel right at home, transforming a simple dining experience into something memorable. If you’re in New Braunfels and craving pizza, don’t miss out on Calahan's; it's a slice of heaven that will leave you longing for more! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best barbacoa in San Antonio.

Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen

Highlights
Delicious Detroit-style pizza
Rustic and laid-back atmosphere
Live music on open mic nights
Great craft beer selection
Friendly and attentive staff

During my recent trip to Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen, I was eagerly anticipating a slice of delightful indulgence—and let me tell you, I was not disappointed! Their Detroit-style pizza is truly a standout; the crust was thick and perfectly crispy, creating a harmonious balance with the rich, cheesy topping. Each slice felt like a warm embrace, making it impossible to stop at just one!

The atmosphere is wonderfully rustic and laid-back, perfect for enjoying both great food and excellent company. On the night I visited, the strains of live music filled the air, enhancing the already vibrant vibe. It’s that perfect spot where you can unwind and savor each mouthwatering bite while tapping your foot to local tunes.

Let’s not forget about the craft beer selection—it complements the pizza beautifully. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that my experience was memorable from start to finish. In a town known for its food, Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen rises above, crafting not just pizza, but an entire dining experience that's worth returning to again and again.

You might also want to check out the best shopping in San Antonio.

Mattenga's Trailer New Braunfels

Highlights
Honey Bexar pizza is great
Delicious pizza rolls
Freshly made with love
Daily deals for loyal customers
Customer feedback valued

Mattenga's Trailer New Braunfels is a delightful find that truly captures the spirit of delicious pizza with a unique flair. As I approached the charming trailer, the aroma of freshly baked dough lured me in, promising an adventure for my taste buds. The first bite of their Honey Bexar pizza, a captivating blend of sweet and savory, was a revelation. The crust was perfectly crispy, adorned with just the right amount of toppings that danced in harmony.

But pizza aficionados, don’t overlook their mouthwatering pizza rolls! These little bundles of joy are oozing with flavor and are perfect for sharing—or keeping all to yourself! What stood out to me was the palpable passion in every dish, reflecting the love and care from the kitchen staff.

I also appreciated their diligence in valuing customer feedback and incorporating daily deals that truly cater to loyal patrons. It’s heartwarming to see a place that combines quality with community spirit. If you’re in the area and craving a slice of excellence, Mattenga’s should be at the top of your must-try list. Trust me, you’ll leave with your heart—and stomach—full!

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in San Antonio.

Crust Pizza Co. - New Braunfels

Highlights
Warm and welcoming atmosphere
Exceptional staff and service
Pizza cooked to perfection
Delicious garlic knots
Great value for money

Nestled in the heart of New Braunfels, Crust Pizza Co. is a true gem that tantalizes the taste buds while offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere. From the moment I stepped inside, I felt like I was part of the family. The staff was exceptionally attentive and friendly, making me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk pizza! My slice arrived and it was cooked to perfection—crisp yet chewy crust that strikes the ideal balance. Each bite boasted a delightful medley of fresh toppings. But let's not forget the garlic knots; these bite-sized wonders were the ideal prelude to my main event, with a flavor that danced merrily on my palate.

What's even better? The value for money is outstanding. For the quality and experience you get, it feels like a steal! If you're in the mood for a delightful pizza experience, I genuinely recommend Crust Pizza Co. in New Braunfels. It’s a place where every bite feels like a warm hug and every visit feels like coming home. Enjoy your pizza adventure!

You might also want to check out the best movers in San Antonio.

Stout's Pizza Co.

Highlights
Inconsistent pizza quality
Friendly staff and service
Great late-night option
Thin and crispy option
Welcoming atmosphere

Stepping into Stout's Pizza Co., I was greeted by a cheerful atmosphere that instantly set a relaxed tone. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, as if I were part of their pizza-loving family. Now, let’s dig into the heart of the matter—the pizza itself.

I opted for the thin and crispy crust, which is always a daring choice, particularly for a place like this that has been known for its inconsistent quality. However, I was pleasantly surprised! This pie had the perfect balance of crunch and flavor, and the toppings were both fresh and abundant. Each bite was a delightful adventure, showcasing their commitment to crafting delicious pizzas.

Though I did notice a couple of unevenness in some friends' orders, the overall experience was buoyed by the friendly service. Plus, if you find yourself out late and hungry, this spot is a solid late-night option.

In conclusion, Stout's Pizza Co. is a delightful addition to New Braunfels’ pizza scene. With its inviting vibe and a solid lineup of pizzas, I’d say it’s worth a visit—even if it's just for a late-night slice under the stars!

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in San Antonio.

Noli's Vite

Highlights
Excellent garlic knots
Generous and flavorful portions
Amazing dessert selections
Consistent excellent service
Relaxed and nice atmosphere

Noli's Vite in New Braunfels is a true gem for pizza lovers! As I walked into the restaurant, I was greeted with a relaxed atmosphere that instantly put me at ease. The aroma of their garlic knots wafted through the air, and I couldn't resist ordering them as an appetizer. Let me tell you, those knots are a delightful start that perfectly sets the stage for the main event.

When the pizza arrived, I was struck by the generous portions and bold flavors. Each slice was a masterpiece, with a crust that struck the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. One bite and I was hooked! What impressed me the most, though, was the consistently excellent service. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure my dining experience was seamless.

And just when I thought the meal couldn't get any better, I was tempted by their amazing dessert selections. I opted for their signature dessert and it was the cherry on top of an already fantastic meal. All in all, Noli's Vite is a must-visit for anyone craving exceptional pizza in New Braunfels. It’s a delightful culinary adventure that I can't wait to embark on again!

You might also want to check out the best banks in San Antonio.

Di's Homemade Pizza

Highlights
Perfect post-tubing stop
Fast and friendly service
Outdoor and pet-friendly seating
Delicious and plentiful toppings
Affordable for large groups

From the moment I stepped into Di's Homemade Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. Nestled conveniently, it’s the perfect stop after a long day of tubing on the river. The atmosphere is as inviting as their fast and friendly service, making it hard not to feel at home.

What really caught my attention was the affordability, especially for larger groups — a huge plus when you’re out with friends! The menu is practically a treasure trove for pizza lovers, featuring delicious and plentiful toppings. I opted for a classic pepperoni with some unexpected additions, and each bite was a flavor explosion.

I also appreciated their outdoor, pet-friendly seating. It’s a delightful option for those who want to enjoy the charm of New Braunfels’ sun while dining al fresco — and isn’t it great to have your furry friends with you?

Overall, Di's Homemade Pizza is not just another pizzeria; it’s a slice of the community that brings people together. Whether you’re refueling after an adventure or catching up with friends, this place checks all the boxes for a satisfying and fun meal. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in San Antonio.

Bella Sera New Braunfels

Highlights
Wonderful owner and staff
Delicious lunch specials
Generous portion sizes
Amazing dining experience
Friendly service throughout

Bella Sera New Braunfels is truly a gem in the bustling pizza landscape of New Braunfels. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a wonderfully warm atmosphere that felt like a cozy embrace after a long day. The staff members were not just friendly; they seemed genuinely enthusiastic about sharing their love for pizza. That kind of passion is infectious!

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the enticing lunch specials that were both affordable and delicious. I decided to try one of their signature pizzas, and let me tell you, the portions were generous enough to feel like a feast! The crust was perfectly crisp, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful, showcasing the kitchen's commitment to quality.

What truly made my experience unforgettable, though, was the inviting dining atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where you can linger, savoring each bite, and sharing laughter with friends. I left Bella Sera not just satisfied, but excited to return. If you’re on the hunt for some of the best pizza in New Braunfels, I wholeheartedly recommend treating yourself to this delightful spot. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best home builders in San Antonio.

DoubleDave's Pizzaworks

Highlights
Incredible pizza flavors
Outstanding desserts
Great price-value ratio
Clean and tidy environment
Comfortable seating

DoubleDave's Pizzaworks in New Braunfels is a delightful haven for pizza lovers! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a clean and tidy environment that promised a great dining experience. The atmosphere felt cozy, making it the perfect spot to sink my teeth into some delicious slices.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza – it was nothing short of phenomenal! The range of flavors offered is truly incredible. I tried their house special which boasted a perfect blend of fresh toppings and a delightful crust that was just the right thickness. Each bite was a savory adventure. What stood out even more was their great price-value ratio; you truly get a fantastic meal without breaking the bank.

And I can’t forget about the desserts! The sweet treats at DoubleDave’s are just the cherry on top of an already splendid meal.

It's a place that combines great pizza with a lovely atmosphere, making it a must-visit in New Braunfels. If you’re searching for the best pizza, look no further than DoubleDave's. Your taste buds will thank you! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best daycares in San Antonio.