New Braunfels' Best Pizza [Updated 2024]

I have scoured every corner of this charming town, tasting and savoring slices from fifteen different pizzerias. From classic Italian joints to trendy fusion spots, I've left no crust unturned in my quest to find the perfect pie.

So grab a napkin and prepare to embark on a mouth-watering journey with me. Together, we will uncover the hidden gems, the cheesy delights, and the toppings that make all the difference.

Get ready to sink your teeth into the best pizza New Braunfels has to offer!

Bootleggers Pizza Parlor

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Great variety of toppings
Friendly staff
Cozy atmosphere

From the moment I walked through the doors, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, instantly making my taste buds tingle with excitement. The menu offered a great variety of toppings, ensuring that there was something for everyone's taste.

I decided to go with their signature pizza, and boy, was I in for a treat! The first bite revealed a perfect harmony of flavors. The crust was crispy and golden, providing the perfect base for the generous amount of gooey cheese that melted in my mouth. Every bite was a delightful explosion of taste, with a smorgasbord of toppings that included juicy sausage, crisp bell peppers, and tangy olives.

What impressed me the most about Bootleggers Pizza Parlor was the friendly staff. They were attentive and knowledgeable, offering recommendations and making sure all my needs were met. The cozy atmosphere added to the overall experience, making me feel right at home.

If you're in the mood for a truly delicious pizza in New Braunfels, Bootleggers Pizza Parlor should be on the top of your list. With their wide variety of toppings, friendly staff, and cozy atmosphere, they have cemented their spot as one of the best pizza joints in town. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in San Antonio.

Above Ground Pizza

Highlights
Great food
Welcoming service
Excellent garlic ring and calzone
Clean and hospitable environment
Kid-friendly atmosphere

Upon entering Above Ground Pizza, I was greeted by an absolutely welcoming service. The staff's genuine smiles and helpful attitudes were an instant indication that I was in for a treat. It didn't take long for me to feel at ease in the clean and hospitable environment.

Now, let's talk about the highlight of any pizza joint - the food! Above Ground Pizza did not disappoint. The flavors were outstanding, and I found myself thoroughly savoring each bite. The garlic ring was a standout, perfectly seasoned and baked to perfection. The calzone was simply divine, with a delectable blend of cheeses and fillings that had me reaching for another slice.

What impressed me the most was the kid-friendly atmosphere. Families with children were clearly made to feel welcome, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure everyone had an enjoyable dining experience. It's always a pleasure to find a place where both parents and kids can indulge in delicious pizza without any fuss.

Overall, I must say that Above Ground Pizza has truly earned its place in the lineup of the best pizza joints in New Braunfels. The combination of great food, welcoming service, and a kid-friendly atmosphere make it a must-visit spot for any pizza lover in town. Don't miss out on their excellent garlic ring and calzone – you'll be in pizza heaven!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in San Antonio.

New York Pizza Pub

Highlights
NY trained
Friendly staff
Wonderful atmosphere
Well stocked bar
Great pizza

Firstly, it's important to note that the owners of New York Pizza Pub are trained in the art of pizza-making in none other than the concrete jungle itself, New York City. This fact alone sets the stage for an authentic pizza experience.

As soon as I walked through the doors, I was greeted by a friendly staff who seemed genuinely happy to have us there. The atmosphere of the place was wonderful, with cozy booths and dimmed lighting. It had that perfect balance of being both classy and casual, making it an ideal spot for a pizza night with friends or a cozy date.

Speaking of the bar, I was pleasantly surprised by the wide selection of beverages. Whether you fancy a craft beer, a fine wine, or even a signature cocktail, they've got you covered. It's clear they take pride in their well-stocked bar, providing options to complement your pizza perfectly.

Now let's get to the real star of the show – the pizza. Oh boy, did it deliver. Each bite was a slice of heaven. The crust had a delightful crispness to it, while remaining chewy and flavorful. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, with an impressive variety to choose from. I couldn't resist going for a classic Margherita and it hit the spot with its perfect blend of gooey mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and fragrant basil.

New York Pizza Pub certainly deserves a spot in the best pizza joints in New Braunfels. From their NY trained staff to their friendly service, charming atmosphere, and let's not forget about the great pizza, this is a place where you'll want to return time and time again.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Antonio.

Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers New Braunfels

Highlights
Delicious food
Surprisingly low prices
Great lunch specials
Family-friendly atmosphere
Cool game room for kids

Let me start by saying, wow! This place exceeded all my expectations. When I walked in, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a family outing. The smell of delicious food filled the air, instantly making my mouth water.

The menu offered a variety of options, but I was here for the pizza. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, just how I like it. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with each bite bursting with mouthwatering goodness. And the best part? The prices were surprisingly low! I couldn't believe the quality I was getting for such a reasonable price.

If you're looking for a great lunch spot, you're in luck. Bosses Pizza, Wings, & Burgers offers fantastic lunch specials that are sure to satisfy even the pickiest eaters. And if you have kids in tow, they'll love the cool game room while you enjoy your meal.

Overall, my experience at Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers New Braunfels was a delightful one. With their delicious food, affordable prices, and family-friendly atmosphere, they have truly earned their spot in the list of the best pizza places in New Braunfels. Don't just take my word for it, head over there and experience it for yourself. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in San Antonio.

Di's Homemade Pizza

Highlights
Amazing
Delicious
Comfort at home
Homemade pizza

Stepping into Di's Homemade Pizza felt like stepping into a small slice of heaven. The cozy atmosphere made me instantly feel comfort at home. As a connoisseur of pizza, my taste buds were ready for the amazing and delicious flavors that awaited me.

Di's Homemade Pizza truly lives up to its name. Each bite reminded me of those homemade pizzas made with love and care. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully fluffy on the inside. Each slice was topped with a generous amount of gooey cheese that melted in my mouth. The sauce, made from scratch, had just the right balance of tanginess and sweetness.

But what truly sets Di's Homemade Pizza apart is their attention to detail. The toppings were thoughtfully selected and arranged, creating a beautiful and enticing visual display. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that every aspect of my dining experience was enjoyable.

Overall, my visit to Di's Homemade Pizza was a delightful experience. The combination of amazing flavors, comfort at home atmosphere, and the knowledge that each pizza is made with love and care truly sets this place apart. If you're in New Braunfels and craving a slice of homemade pizza, be sure to visit Di's Homemade Pizza. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in San Antonio.

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits

Highlights
Cool and unique food and drink
Amazing food and great drinks
Wood-fired pizza comes out quick
$5 margaritas
New go-to spot for pizza

Let me start by saying, Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits is not your average pizza joint. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place was something special. The first thing that caught my eye was their cool and unique food and drink options. I mean, where else can you find wood-fired pizza and killer cocktails all in one place?

Speaking of the food, let me just say, the pizzas here are amazing. The wood-fired oven gives the crust a perfect crispiness, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors that left me wanting more. And the best part? The pizzas come out quick. There's nothing worse than waiting forever for your food, especially when you're craving a deliciously cheesy slice of pizza.

Now, let me talk about the drinks. Inferno's offers a variety of spirits that pair perfectly with their pizzas. And let me tell you, their $5 margaritas are a game-changer. Nothing beats sipping on a perfectly mixed margarita while enjoying a slice of piping hot pizza.

Overall, Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits has become my new go-to spot for pizza in New Braunfels. The combination of their delicious food, great drinks, and unique atmosphere make it a standout in the pizza scene. So if you're looking for a playful yet professional pizza experience, I highly recommend giving Inferno's a try. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in San Antonio.

Stout's Pizza Co.

Highlights
Great service
Fresh and tasty pizza
Homemade crust and marinara sauce
Support local companies

From the moment I walked into Stout's Pizza Co., I could tell that I was in for a treat. The friendly and attentive staff provided great service, making me feel welcomed and valued as a customer.

As I perused the menu, I noticed a wide variety of pizza options to choose from. I ultimately decided on a classic pepperoni pizza, as it's the true test of any pizzeria's skill. I eagerly awaited my pizza's arrival, and when it finally did, I couldn't help but be impressed.

First and foremost, the pizza was incredibly fresh and bursting with flavor. Every bite was a delight to my taste buds. The secret, I learned, was in the homemade crust and marinara sauce. These homemade elements elevated the pizza to a whole new level.

But what truly set Stout's Pizza Co. apart was their commitment to supporting local companies. Every ingredient used in their pizzas was sourced locally, which not only added to the freshness, but also ensured that I was supporting the community.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in New Braunfels and are craving a delicious and authentic pizza experience, look no further than Stout's Pizza Co. With their great service, fresh and tasty pizza, and dedication to using homemade crust and marinara sauce, they have certainly earned a spot as one of the best pizza establishments in town.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in San Antonio.

Cicis Pizza

Highlights
Good food
Friendly service
Wheelchair friendly
Polite and professional staff
Delicious and fresh food

Walking into Cicis Pizza in New Braunfels, I couldn't help but feel a wave of excitement. The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, making my taste buds tingle with anticipation. As I made my way to the counter, I was greeted with a warm smile from the friendly staff, who were not only polite, but also displayed a high level of professionalism.

What impressed me the most about Cicis Pizza was their commitment to providing a wheelchair-friendly environment. The spacious layout allowed for easy maneuverability, ensuring that everyone, regardless of their mobility, could enjoy their dining experience.

As I settled into a cozy booth, I couldn't help but admire the variety of pizzas on display. From classic pepperoni to creative combinations like BBQ Chicken and Mac & Cheese, the options were truly impressive. I decided to try a slice of each, eager to sample the goodness.

With every bite, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the ingredients. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the cheese was gooey and melted to perfection. Each pizza was bursting with flavor, and it was evident that the food was made with fresh ingredients.

Throughout my visit, the service remained top-notch. The staff checked on me frequently, ensuring that I had everything I needed. It was evident that they took pride in their work and genuinely cared about their customers' dining experience.

In conclusion, Cicis Pizza in New Braunfels is an excellent choice for pizza lovers. With its good food, friendly service, and commitment to accessibility, it undoubtedly deserves a spot among the best pizza places in town. So, if you find yourself craving a delicious and fresh pizza, don't hesitate to pay Cicis Pizza a visit.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Braunfels.

MOD Pizza

Highlights
Outstanding food
Great service
Quick problem resolution

Let me just say, MOD Pizza in New Braunfels exceeded my expectations in every way.

From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with a warm smile and a friendly welcome. The staff at MOD Pizza really know how to make you feel like a valued customer.

Now let's talk about the pizza itself. Oh my goodness, the flavors that greeted my taste buds were truly outstanding. I opted for a custom-made pie, and I must say, the toppings were fresh, the crust was perfectly cooked, and the sauce was simply divine. Each bite was a burst of pure pizza bliss.

But what really impressed me was the level of service I received. When I had a minor issue with my order, the staff at MOD Pizza quickly and efficiently resolved it. They listened attentively to my concerns and went above and beyond to make sure I left as a satisfied customer.

I could see that this level of dedication to customer satisfaction was a priority at MOD Pizza. The staff took the time to genuinely connect with each customer, and their attention to detail was truly commendable.

All in all, my experience at MOD Pizza in New Braunfels was absolutely delightful. From the outstanding food to the great service and quick problem resolution, it's clear to me why this place deserves a spot among the best pizza joints in town. I can't wait to go back and try more of their mouthwatering creations.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Antonio.

Little Caesars Pizza

Highlights
Hot and ready
Crazy bread
Never soggy
Stuffed crust
Friendly staff

The first thing that caught my attention about Little Caesars Pizza was their claim of being "Hot and Ready" – and let me tell you, they did not disappoint! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizzas. The staff was friendly and promptly handed me a piping hot slice.

The pizza itself was a delight. The crust was crispy and never soggy, which is a common issue with many other pizzerias. The cheese was perfectly melted, and the sauce had just the right balance of tanginess and sweetness. I particularly enjoyed their stuffed crust option, which added an extra layer of cheesy goodness to every bite.

But what really stole the show for me was their Crazy Bread. These warm and buttery breadsticks were the perfect accompaniment to the pizza. They were soft on the inside and had a satisfying crunch on the outside. One bite and I was in breadstick heaven.

Overall, my experience at Little Caesars Pizza in New Braunfels was fantastic. The hot and ready pizzas, never soggy crust, and crazy bread made for a truly delightful meal. If you're looking for a quick and delicious pizza fix, I highly recommend giving Little Caesars a try. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in San Antonio.

DoubleDave's Pizzaworks

DoubleDave's Pizzaworks in New Braunfels is a playground for pizza lovers like me! Their pies are irresistibly cheesy and topped to perfection. Trust me, I couldn't resist ordering an extra slice (or three). From the tangy sauce to the crispy crust, every bite was pizza perfection.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in San Antonio.

Peter Piper Pizza

Peter Piper Pizza in New Braunfels is a playful and professional pizza joint with flavors that will make your taste buds dance. Their crispy crust and abundance of toppings make every bite a delight. Whether you're enjoying a cheese-only classic or a bold and zesty combination, this place is a pizza paradise.

You might also want to check out the best tex mex in San Antonio.

Calahan's Pub and Pizza

Calahan's Pub and Pizza in New Braunfels is a hidden gem for pizza lovers! The dough is perfection, providing a chewy and crispy crust that holds up to the generous toppings. The flavorful sauce takes you on a saucy journey, while the premium cheese melts into ooey-gooey goodness. A delightfully playful yet professional spot for pizza enthusiasts.

Marco's Pizza

Marco's Pizza in New Braunfels delivers the perfect blend of playful and professional. With a wide variety of toppings and a crust that's both crispy and deliciously chewy, it's no wonder this joint stands out among the rest. Get your taste buds fired up and head on over to Marco's!

Pizza Hut

With a playful yet professional style, allow me to present my short, 50-word review of Pizza Hut in New Braunfels:

"Searching for the best pizza in New Braunfels led me straight to Pizza Hut. With their impressive variety of toppings and crispy, delicious crust, Pizza Hut proved to be a satisfying choice. Whether you're in the mood for classics or bold combos, Pizza Hut has something to please** every pizza aficionado.”