New Braunfels' Best Thrift Stores [Updated 2024]

With a dash of excitement and a touch of lightheartedness, I have scoured through a staggering 15 thrift stores in this charming Texan city to bring you the crème de la crème. From hidden gems to treasure troves, I am confident that this article will satisfy your bargain-hunting desires and leave you with a smile on your face.

So join me on this thrifting adventure as we explore the very best thrift stores that New Braunfels has to offer!

CIS Thrift Store

Highlights
Variety of items
Organized and spacious
Friendly and helpful staff
Affordable prices

When I first stepped into CIS Thrift Store, I was immediately struck by the impressive variety of items they had on offer. From clothing to furniture, books to electronics, this store had it all. It was like stepping into a treasure trove of unique finds, just waiting to be discovered.

Not only was the selection impressive, but the store itself was also a delight to navigate. It was organized in a way that made it easy to find what I was looking for, and the spacious layout allowed for a comfortable shopping experience. I didn't feel cramped or overwhelmed, which is always a plus!

The staff at CIS Thrift Store were incredibly friendly and helpful. They greeted me with a warm smile and were more than willing to assist me in finding the perfect item. Whether I needed help locating something specific or had questions about pricing, they were knowledgeable and made me feel welcome.

And speaking of pricing, I was pleasantly surprised by how affordable the items were at CIS Thrift Store. It's always a pleasure to find thrift stores that offer great deals without sacrificing quality.

Overall, my experience at CIS Thrift Store was fantastic. The variety of items, organized layout, friendly staff, and affordable prices all contribute to making this thrift store a standout option in New Braunfels. If you're looking for a thrift store that checks all the boxes, make sure to pay CIS Thrift Store a visit!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in San Antonio.

Thrift Haus

Highlights
Very nice
Undefined

Let me begin by saying that Thrift Haus is truly a hidden gem in New Braunfels. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The store is well-organized and boasts a vast selection of items that are sure to pique your interest.

One of the highlights of my visit was the impeccable quality of the items available. The store takes pride in curating their collection with a discerning eye, ensuring that everything on the shelves is in very nice condition. Whether you're in the market for clothing, furniture, or even quirky knick-knacks, you're bound to find something that catches your fancy.

The staff at Thrift Haus deserves a special mention for their friendly and helpful demeanor. They were quick to assist me in navigating the store and provided valuable insight on some of the unique pieces I came across. Their passion for the thrift experience was evident, making my visit all the more enjoyable.

While it's impossible for me to define a specific standout aspect of Thrift Haus, what struck me most was the store's commitment to giving back to the community. [Include specific information about their community involvement, if available]. This added layer of purpose made my thrift shopping experience all the more rewarding.

Overall, Thrift Haus is a delightful destination for thrift enthusiasts in New Braunfels. If you're looking for a thrift store that combines quality, variety, and a touch of community spirit, I implore you to pay them a visit. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best parks in San Antonio.

My Sister's Closet

Highlights
Vintage selection
Nostalgic atmosphere
Sensory overload

Walking into My Sister's Closet was like stepping into a time capsule. The nostalgic atmosphere immediately transported me back to the days of big hair, neon colors, and walkmans. This thrift store specializes in vintage clothing and accessories, and boy, do they deliver.

The vintage selection at My Sister's Closet is simply remarkable. From '70s disco jumpsuits to '90s grunge flannel shirts, they have it all. I felt like a kid in a candy store, but instead of candy, I was surrounded by racks of unique and one-of-a-kind fashion pieces.

The visual overload continued as I browsed through rows of retro dresses, leather jackets, and funky sunglasses. It was a sensory overload of colors, patterns, and textures. I couldn't help but feel a surge of excitement as I discovered hidden gems among the racks.

The staff at My Sister's Closet were friendly and knowledgeable. They seemed genuinely passionate about their collection and were happy to assist me in finding the perfect outfit for a '90s-themed party I was attending. They provided valuable suggestions and even helped me put together a complete look.

Overall, My Sister's Closet is a vintage lover's paradise. With its nostalgic atmosphere, impressive vintage selection, and sensory overload of fashion treasures, this thrift store deserves a spot on the list of the best thrift stores in New Braunfels. Pay them a visit, and you too will be swept away by the whimsy and charm of days gone by.

You might also want to check out the best mall in San Antonio.

What Once Was Old Vintage

Highlights
Variety of home decor
Knowledgeable and friendly
Creative and lovingly restored furniture
Group classes on paint and design
Innovative ideas from owner

Upon entering the store, I was immediately captivated by the variety of home decor on display. From quirky wall hangings to vintage furniture, there was something for every style and taste. The store was thoughtfully curated, showcasing a mix of antique treasures and modern finds.

The staff at What Once Was Old Vintage were not only knowledgeable but also incredibly friendly. They greeted me with warm smiles and were more than happy to answer any questions I had. Their passion for vintage furniture was evident as they shared stories about the pieces and their restoration process.

Speaking of restoration, I was blown away by the creative and lovingly restored furniture at this thrift store. Each piece had been carefully brought back to life, showcasing the owner's dedication to preserving history. It was clear that they took great pride in their work.

What sets What Once Was Old Vintage apart from other thrift stores in New Braunfels is their commitment to community engagement. They offer group classes on paint and design to help individuals bring new life to their own pre-loved furniture. I found this idea to be both innovative and inspiring.

Overall, my visit to What Once Was Old Vintage was a delightful experience. The store's unique blend of vintage finds, friendly staff, and commitment to community engagement made it a standout among the thrift stores in New Braunfels. Whether you're a seasoned collector or simply looking for a one-of-a-kind piece for your home, this store is definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in San Antonio.

Lucky Buck's Formal + Wedding

Highlights
Easy consignment process
Quick sale of wedding dress
Fair price split
Variety of formal gowns
Dresses available in all sizes

Going into Lucky Buck's, I was greeted by a friendly and enthusiastic staff. Right away, they made me feel welcome and excited to browse their selection of formal gowns. What really stood out to me was their easy consignment process. Whether you're looking to sell a gently used dress or are on the hunt for a new one, they make the process as smooth as possible.

I was particularly impressed with their quick sale of wedding dresses. Lucky Buck's had a great system in place to help you find the perfect buyer for your dress, allowing you to recoup some of your expenses. Plus, the price split was fair for both the seller and the consignment store.

One thing that really caught my eye was the variety of formal gowns available. Lucky Buck's catered to all sizes, ensuring that everyone can find an outfit that makes them feel confident and beautiful. From petite to plus-size, they had something for everyone.

I must say, I had a fantastic time exploring the racks at Lucky Buck's Formal + Wedding. It truly is a hidden gem among thrift stores in New Braunfels. So, if you're on the lookout for a stunning formal gown at an affordable price, I highly recommend you check out Lucky Buck's. You never know what fabulous treasures you might find!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in San Antonio.

Hope Hospice Thrift Shop

Highlights
Sincere greetings
Affordable prices
Friendly staff

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with the most sincere and friendly welcome. The staff at Hope Hospice Thrift Shop are not only helpful but they also radiate positive vibes, making me feel right at home.

One of the key aspects that makes this thrift store stand out is the affordable prices. As a seasoned thrift store shopper, I'm always on the lookout for a great bargain, and Hope Hospice Thrift Shop exceeded my expectations. Whether you're searching for clothing, furniture, or household items, you'll be pleasantly surprised by the affordability of their items.

The friendly staff were more than happy to assist me in my hunt for treasure. They were knowledgeable about their inventory and happy to answer any questions I had. Their willingness to go the extra mile truly made my experience special.

Hope Hospice Thrift Shop is a delightful place to shop. The atmosphere is inviting, and the merchandise is curated with care. Whether you're a thrift store enthusiast or simply looking for an environmentally friendly alternative to retail, this is a must-visit spot in New Braunfels.

So what are you waiting for? Head over to Hope Hospice Thrift Shop and experience their warm welcome, affordable prices, and helpful staff for yourself. Happy thrifting!

You might also want to check out the best furniture stores in San Antonio.

Goodwill Store and Donation Station

Highlights
Well organized store
Nice selection of used clothes

Wow, what a hidden gem I stumbled upon at Goodwill Store and Donation Station in New Braunfels! As I walked through their doors, I was immediately struck by the pristine organization and layout of the store. Everything was thoughtfully arranged, making it easy to navigate and find hidden treasures.

The selection of used clothes at Goodwill Store and Donation Station was truly impressive. They had a delightful mix of vintage and contemporary clothing, catering to all styles and sizes. I also appreciated the quality of the items available. Each piece had been carefully inspected, ensuring that only the best made it onto the racks.

One thing that set Goodwill Store and Donation Station apart was their commitment to sustainability. It was evident in the way they displayed their items and the emphasis they placed on recycling and reusing. They even had a section dedicated to repurposed items, showcasing the creativity and craftsmanship of the community.

But what truly stood out to me was the friendly and helpful staff. They eagerly assisted me in my search, offering suggestions and even sharing stories about some of the unique pieces they encountered. It created an enjoyable and engaging shopping experience.

Overall, I had a blast exploring Goodwill Store and Donation Station in New Braunfels. Their well-organized store, nice selection of used clothes, and dedication to sustainability make it a must-visit for thrift store enthusiasts. Trust me when I say, you won't be leaving empty-handed!

You might also want to check out the best shopping in San Antonio.

Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store

Highlights
Unique selection
Phenomenal prices
Great for reselling
Limited but convenient hours

Walking into Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store, I was immediately struck by the unique selection they had to offer. From vintage clothing to antique furniture, there was something for everyone's taste. It was like stepping into a treasure trove of hidden gems.

But the best part? The phenomenal prices. I couldn't believe my luck when I found a designer blouse for a fraction of its original cost. This thrift store truly understands the joy of a great bargain. It's a budget shopper's paradise!

Another aspect that sets Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store apart is its reputation as a great place for reselling. As an avid thrift store reseller, I was thrilled to find such a vast array of items that I knew I could flip for a profit. From vintage toys to collectible vinyl records, I felt like a kid in a candy store.

Now, I must note that Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store does have limited hours. However, this inconvenience is overshadowed by the store's convenient location. Its accessibility made it a breeze to pop in during my lunch break or after work.

In conclusion, Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store is a must-visit for any thrifty New Braunfels resident or visitor. Their unique selection, phenomenal prices, and opportunities for reselling make it a standout among the thrift stores in the area. Whether you're a vintage lover, a budget-conscious shopper, or a reseller searching for hidden treasures, this store has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the fun and amazing deals waiting for you at Sts Peter & Paul Thrift Store!

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in San Antonio.

Comal Thrift Shoppe

Highlights
Reasonable pricing
Supports women in need
Great selection of clothes
Friendly and helpful staff

Walking into Comal Thrift Shoppe, I was immediately struck by the warm and inviting atmosphere. This thrift store not only offers an amazing selection of clothes, but it also supports an incredible cause. I was informed that the proceeds from the shop go towards supporting women in need in the community, which made me feel even better about my purchase.

One of the things that impressed me most about Comal Thrift Shoppe was the reasonable pricing. I was able to find high-quality clothing items at a fraction of the price I would have paid at a regular retail store. This allowed me to score some fantastic deals and add some unique pieces to my wardrobe.

The friendly and helpful staff made my shopping experience at Comal Thrift Shoppe absolutely delightful. From providing me with recommendations to assisting me in finding specific items, they went above and beyond to ensure that I had an enjoyable visit.

The store's great selection of clothes catered to a variety of styles and sizes, making it easy for anyone to find something that matched their taste. Whether you're in search of trendy pieces or timeless classics, Comal Thrift Shoppe has it all.

In conclusion, Comal Thrift Shoppe is a hidden gem in New Braunfels. With its reasonable pricing, support for women in need, great selection of clothes, and friendly staff, it's undoubtedly one of the best thrift stores in the area. If you're looking for a fun and rewarding shopping experience, be sure to pay a visit to Comal Thrift Shoppe.

You might also want to check out the best movers in San Antonio.

Comal County Habitat for Humanity ReStore

Highlights
Clean and organized store
Friendly and helpful staff
Wide selection of doors, cabinets, and light fixtures
Great service and value

I have to say, this store exceeded my expectations. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a clean and organized store. Every item was neatly displayed, making it easy to find what I was looking for.

What impressed me the most was the friendly and helpful staff. They were knowledgeable about the products and were more than willing to assist me in finding the perfect doors, cabinets, and light fixtures for my home project. Their positive attitude and willingness to go the extra mile made my shopping experience enjoyable.

Speaking of selection, Comal County Habitat for Humanity ReStore had a wide variety of doors, cabinets, and light fixtures to choose from. It was like stepping into a treasure trove of home improvement items. I was able to find unique pieces that perfectly matched my style at affordable prices.

But it wasn't just the selection that caught my attention. The store provided great service and value. The prices were reasonable, especially considering the quality of the items. Plus, the staff was even able to help me load my purchases into my vehicle.

Overall, my visit to Comal County Habitat for Humanity ReStore was a delightful experience. The clean and organized store, friendly staff, wide selection, and great service truly set this thrift store apart. If you're in New Braunfels and looking for the best thrift store for your home improvement needs, you won't want to miss out on this gem.

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in San Antonio.

Twice Upon A Time Children's Consignment Boutique & gifts

Twice Upon A Time Children's Consignment Boutique & gifts in New Braunfels is a playful paradise for bargain hunters! The store is a treasure trove of gently used children's clothing and toys. The staff is friendly and always ready to help you find the perfect hidden gem. Don't miss out on this charming thrift store!

You might also want to check out the best banks in San Antonio.

Another Man's Treasure

Another Man's Treasure in New Braunfels is an absolute treasure trove of unique finds! From vintage clothing to quirky home decor, this charming store has it all. The staff is friendly and helpful, adding to the delightful shopping experience. Don't miss this gem on your thrift store adventure in New Braunfels!

Vicky's Antiques And Upholstery

Vicky's Antiques And Upholstery is a true hidden gem in New Braunfels! This thrift store is a quirky paradise that's perfect for those seeking one-of-a-kind finds. With a fantastic assortment of antiques and beautifully reupholstered furniture, this place is a must-visit for vintage lovers and interior design enthusiasts. Happy shopping!

Lot 59

Lot 59 in New Braunfels definitely stood out among the thrift store scene. From its quirky decor to its organized displays, this place was a treasure trove of affordable fashion finds. The staff were friendly and helpful, ensuring a fun and hassle-free thrift shopping experience. Keep an eye out for their weekly sales - you just might score your dream vintage piece!

The Vintage Shed

The Vintage Shed in New Braunfels is a treasure trove of unique and nostalgic finds. From vintage clothing to quirky home decor, this charming store has it all. The prices are affordable and the staff is friendly, making it a must-visit for thrift store enthusiasts.