The Absolute Best Car Insurance in New Braunfels [Updated 2024]

Hi there! I've spent countless hours digging through the depths of the car insurance world to bring you the crème de la crème in New Braunfels.

If you're like me and value both quality coverage and a lighthearted approach to life, you're in for a treat. With 15 carefully reviewed options, this article will help you effortlessly navigate the maze of insurance policies and find the one that's perfect for you.

So buckle up, because we're about to embark on a journey towards the best car insurance in New Braunfels!

A-MAX Auto Insurance

Highlights
Affordable
Always answer the phone
Super kind
Fast and attentive
Efficient and helpful

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that A-MAX Auto Insurance prioritizes their customers. Not only were they affordable, but their customer service was phenomenal. It's rare to find an insurance company that always answers the phone promptly, but A-MAX Auto Insurance seemed to have it down to a science.

The staff members were not only super kind, but they were also fast and attentive. I didn't have to wait long for assistance, and they made sure to carefully listen to my needs. As someone who values efficiency, I appreciated how efficient and helpful they were throughout my entire visit.

What stood out to me the most about A-MAX Auto Insurance was their dedication to providing top-notch service. They took the time to explain different coverage options and answered all of my questions with patience and expertise. This made me feel confident that I was making the right choice for my car insurance needs.

Overall, A-MAX Auto Insurance in New Braunfels made a lasting impression on me. Their combination of affordability, excellent customer service, and attentiveness sets them apart from other insurance providers. If you're looking for the best car insurance in New Braunfels, I highly recommend giving A-MAX Auto Insurance a visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best car insurance in San Antonio.

Contigo Insurance Agency

Highlights
Christine Lopez Helpful
Great customer service
Elizabeth Agundus Impressed
Above and beyond help
Trustworthy insurance company

Let me start by saying that the staff at Contigo Insurance Agency, particularly Christine Lopez, were incredibly helpful. They went above and beyond to ensure that I got the car insurance coverage that was tailored to my specific needs.

The customer service at Contigo Insurance Agency was exceptional. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a friendly smile and treated with utmost professionalism. Elizabeth Agundus, one of the agents, impressed me with her knowledge and expertise. She patiently answered all of my questions and took the time to explain the different coverage options available to me.

What sets Contigo Insurance Agency apart from other insurance companies is their commitment to going the extra mile. Not only did they find me a policy that fit my budget, but they also added valuable extras that I hadn't even considered. It's that attention to detail and willingness to go above and beyond that makes Contigo Insurance Agency stand out.

The peace of mind that comes with knowing you're dealing with a trustworthy insurance company is priceless. Contigo Insurance Agency has built a reputation for providing reliable coverage and excellent customer service, and my experience with them confirmed just that.

When it comes to finding the best car insurance in New Braunfels, I highly recommend giving Contigo Insurance Agency a call. Their helpfulness, great customer service, and dedication to going above and beyond truly set them apart.

You might also want to check out the best parks in San Antonio.

L.A. Insurance

Highlights
Easy and simple insurance process
Affordable auto insurance
Excellent customer service

When it comes to finding the best car insurance in New Braunfels, L.A. Insurance is definitely a top contender. From start to finish, their insurance process was an absolute breeze, making my life so much easier.

One of the highlights of my visit was the affordable auto insurance options they offered. As someone who is always on the lookout for a good deal, I was pleasantly surprised by their competitive rates. I was able to find a policy that fit my needs and budget without any hassle.

But what truly set L.A. Insurance apart from the competition was their excellent customer service. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, taking the time to answer all of my questions and even offering advice on how to further protect my vehicle. They made me feel valued as a customer, which is a quality that is hard to come by these days.

Overall, my experience at L.A. Insurance in New Braunfels was top-notch. Their easy and simple insurance process, affordable rates, and outstanding customer service make them one of the best options for car insurance in the area. If you're looking for coverage that not only protects your vehicle but also provides peace of mind, I highly recommend giving L.A. Insurance a try.

You might also want to check out the best mall in San Antonio.

Comparion Insurance Agency

Highlights
Affordable rates
Stress-free process
Exceptional customer service
Lots of great policy options

First things first, let's talk about the affordable rates they offer. As a savvy consumer, I always appreciate when a company understands the importance of a good deal without compromising on quality. Comparion Insurance Agency definitely fits the bill - they offer competitive rates that won't break the bank.

But what really won me over was their stress-free process. Nobody likes dealing with complicated paperwork and endless phone calls, especially when it comes to car insurance. Comparion Insurance Agency made the whole experience a breeze. From getting a quote to actually signing up for a policy, everything was smooth sailing.

And let's not forget about their exceptional customer service. The staff at Comparion Insurance Agency were knowledgeable, friendly, and went above and beyond to answer all my questions. They truly made me feel valued as a customer.

Lastly, Comparion Insurance Agency offers lots of great policy options. No matter what your specific needs are, they have a policy that will suit you. Whether you're looking for basic coverage or comprehensive protection, they've got you covered.

In conclusion, Comparion Insurance Agency impressed me with their affordability, stress-free process, exceptional customer service, and wide range of policy options. If you're on the hunt for the best car insurance in New Braunfels, I highly recommend giving them a call. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in San Antonio.

Tunnell Insurance

Highlights
Saved money on insurance
Amazing team that answers questions
Quick assistance when needed
Provides best rates

When it comes to finding the best car insurance in New Braunfels, Tunnell Insurance certainly stands out. From the moment I walked through their doors, I knew I was in for a pleasant insurance experience.

First and foremost, Tunnell Insurance helped me save money on my car insurance. Who doesn't love saving some extra cash, right? With their expertise and knowledge of the insurance market, they were able to find me the best rates available, tailored to my specific needs and budget.

But it wasn't just about the savings. The team at Tunnell Insurance was truly amazing. They were friendly, approachable, and always willing to answer any questions I had. They made sure I understood the policies and coverage options, leaving no room for confusion or doubt. It was a refreshing change from the usual insurance jargon.

Moreover, Tunnell Insurance provided quick assistance whenever I needed it. Whether it was filing a claim or updating my policy, they were responsive and efficient. It gave me peace of mind knowing that I had a reliable insurance agency just a phone call away.

All in all, Tunnell Insurance delivered on their promise of providing the best car insurance experience in New Braunfels. They saved me money, had an amazing team, offered quick assistance, and provided the best rates available. If you're in the market for car insurance, I highly recommend giving Tunnell Insurance a visit. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in San Antonio.

Mahan Insurance Services Inc & Nationwide Insurance

Smooth as silk, Mahan Insurance Services Inc & Nationwide Insurance in New Braunfels gets a high-five from me! These folks combine professionalism with a playful touch, offering the best car insurance options in town. Do yourself a favor and book an appointment with them!

You might also want to check out the best furniture stores in San Antonio.

Farmers Insurance - Timothy Brice

Highlights
Great customer service
Kind and down to earth staff
Insurance within your budget
Excellent service from Tim Brice
Caring and helpful agent

First and foremost, I was immediately impressed by the great customer service at this establishment. The staff there were not only knowledgeable but also kind and down to earth. It truly felt like they were genuinely interested in helping me find the best car insurance for my needs.

When it came to finding insurance within my budget, I was pleasantly surprised with the options provided by Timothy Brice. He took the time to understand my financial situation and presented me with a variety of plans that fit my budget perfectly.

I must say that the service provided by Tim Brice himself was exceptional. He was attentive, responsive, and went above and beyond to take care of all my insurance needs. It was clear that he cared about me as a client and was dedicated to providing the best possible service.

One thing that really stood out to me was how much of a caring and helpful agent Tim Brice was. He not only guided me through the process of choosing the right insurance plan but also offered valuable tips and advice on how to maintain a good driving record and save money on premiums.

In conclusion, if you're looking for car insurance in New Braunfels, I highly recommend considering Farmers Insurance - Timothy Brice. With their great customer service, kind and down to earth staff, and insurance options within your budget, you'll be in good hands. My experience with Tim Brice was nothing short of excellent, and I'm confident that others will have the same positive experience.

You might also want to check out the best shopping in San Antonio.

Rosie Garcia - State Farm Insurance Agent

Highlights
Professional and helpful
Best policy and coverage
Simple and quick service

Let me start by saying that Rosie Garcia and her team provide a truly professional and helpful service. From the moment I stepped into their office, I was greeted with a friendly smile that instantly put me at ease.

But it wasn't just the warm welcome that impressed me; it was also the quality of their policies and coverage options. Rosie Garcia - State Farm Insurance Agent offers some of the best policies on the market, tailored to meet the unique needs of drivers in New Braunfels. Whether you're looking for comprehensive coverage or just the basic minimum, they have you covered.

What sets Rosie Garcia apart from the competition is the simplicity and speed of their service. They understand that your time is valuable, and they make the insurance process as efficient as possible. From obtaining a quote to filing a claim, everything is handled with utmost professionalism and efficiency.

After my visit, I can confidently say that Rosie Garcia - State Farm Insurance Agent is one of the top options for car insurance in New Braunfels. Their commitment to providing the best policies and coverage, along with their exceptional customer service, make them a standout choice.

So, if you're on the hunt for car insurance that offers the perfect blend of quality and convenience, I highly recommend giving Rosie Garcia - State Farm Insurance Agent a call. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best movers in San Antonio.

Mallory Shelton at Comparion Insurance Agency

Highlights
Mallory is knowledgeable
She finds the best rates
Mallory goes the extra mile
Clients always come first

Let me start by saying that Mallory is one of the most knowledgeable insurance agents I have encountered. She knows the ins and outs of car insurance policies like the back of her hand. But what truly sets her apart is her ability to find the best rates for her clients.

When I sat down with Mallory, she took the time to understand my unique needs and budget. She didn't try to upsell me on unnecessary coverage or confuse me with insurance jargon. Instead, she presented me with clear and concise options that perfectly aligned with my requirements.

What impressed me the most about Mallory is her willingness to go the extra mile. She not only secured a great policy for me but also made sure I understood every aspect of it. She patiently answered all my questions and provided valuable insights that ultimately helped me make an informed decision.

It's obvious that Mallory genuinely cares about her clients. Her commitment to putting their needs first is commendable. She ensures that her clients receive personalized attention and exceptional service throughout the entire process.

Overall, Mallory Shelton at Comparion Insurance Agency is a top-notch insurance agent. With her extensive knowledge, knack for finding the best rates, and unwavering dedication to her clients, it's no wonder she is considered one of the best in New Braunfels. If you're looking for car insurance that's not only affordable but tailored to your needs, I highly recommend reaching out to Mallory. She's the real deal.

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in San Antonio.

Miller & Miller Insurance Agency

Highlights
Decades of excellent service
Terrific customer service
Handles home and auto policies effectively
Active in the community

Let me tell you, these folks know a thing or two about providing top-notch car insurance. With decades of excellent service, they have certainly made their mark in the industry.

The first thing that stood out to me was their terrific customer service. From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with a genuine smile and a warm welcome. The staff at Miller & Miller Insurance Agency truly understands the importance of building strong relationships with their customers.

Not only do they excel in the car insurance realm, but they are also successful in handling home and auto policies effectively. This is great news for those looking to bundle their policies and save some hard-earned cash.

What really spoke volumes about Miller & Miller Insurance Agency was their commitment to the community. They are actively involved in various local initiatives and sponsorships. It's refreshing to see a company that not only cares about its customers but also cares about giving back.

Overall, my visit to Miller & Miller Insurance Agency was nothing short of delightful. With their decades of experience, terrific customer service, and active involvement in the community, it's no wonder they are considered one of the best car insurance providers in New Braunfels.

So, if you're in the market for car insurance and want to go with a company that truly cares, I highly recommend checking out Miller & Miller Insurance Agency. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best banks in San Antonio.

Farmers Insurance - Jp Kesselring

Farmers Insurance - Jp Kesselring is dazzling with their exemplary customer service and top-notch coverage options. They truly understand the importance of protecting your wheels without breaking the bank. Trust me, Jp Kesselring at Farmers Insurance will have you feeling like a supreme road warrior!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in San Antonio.

Farmers Insurance - Ernest Kenney

Ernest Kenney offers top-notch car insurance coverage that made my ride as smooth as a hot knife through butter. With their playful yet professional attitude, they made insuring my car a breeze. So, if you're in New Braunfels and desire the best car insurance, look no further than Farmers Insurance - Ernest Kenney.

Freeway Insurance

I must say, Freeway Insurance in New Braunfels exceeded my expectations! Their playful yet professional approach made the whole experience enjoyable. The staff was knowledgeable and went above and beyond to find me the best car insurance coverage. With their competitive rates and outstanding customer service, Freeway Insurance definitely deserves a spot in the list of the best car insurance options in New Braunfels.

Texas Insurance

Texas Insurance in New Braunfels is a hidden gem when it comes to car insurance. Their friendly agents provided me with top-notch service and a wide range of coverage options, ensuring that I got the best deal. With their competitive prices and hassle-free claims process, Texas Insurance is definitely a strong contender for the best car insurance in New Braunfels.

Primero Insurance

Primero Insurance, located in charming New Braunfels, impressed me with their excellent service and competitive rates. They have a friendly and knowledgeable staff that made the insurance process a breeze. If you want the best car insurance in town, look no further than Primero Insurance!